What are rates for monks vs cavefish at level 85 with a granite lobster? Is there a better afk method than these two?

They're both around 30-40k an hr at 85.

What about shilo fly fishing with banking?

iirc, shilo is around 50k xp/hr.

 

If you're lazy, inefficient, and enjoy playing Fist of Guthix and Stealing Creation like me, then fishing swordfish w/ swordfish gloves + clay harpoon is 95k xp/hr, and about as AFK as monkfish.

That actually sounds like a seriously good idea. Thanks.

iirc, shilo is around 50k xp/hr.

 

If you're lazy, inefficient, and enjoy playing Fist of Guthix and Stealing Creation like me, then fishing swordfish w/ swordfish gloves + clay harpoon is 95k xp/hr, and about as AFK as monkfish.

Wow. I never considered using my FoG tokens (I love that minigame, no idea why) on swordie gloves. That's awesome.

Fish Flingers used to be the best "AFK" fishing xp by a fairly wide margin, but I dunno what the rates are like post-update.

Fish Flingers used to be the best "AFK" fishing xp by a fairly wide margin, but I dunno what the rates are like post-update.

 

I get about 17-20k at 86 in a match if the combinations and heaviest fish are called soon enough. So that's 17-20k every 18 minutes (10 match, 8 minutes waiting). So that's 56k-66k xp per hour.

If you combine that with shilo fishing (play game, leave, fish at shilo, enter, play game, rince and repeat) with about 6 of the eight minutes spent on fishing in shilo you'll get 101k-116k xp per hour.

 

Of course, this is quite far from AFK that way.

Fish Flingers used to be the best "AFK" fishing xp by a fairly wide margin, but I dunno what the rates are like post-update.

 

I get about 17-20k at 86 in a match if the combinations and heaviest fish are called soon enough. So that's 17-20k every 18 minutes (10 match, 8 minutes waiting). So that's 56k-66k xp per hour.

If you combine that with shilo fishing (play game, leave, fish at shilo, enter, play game, rince and repeat) with about 6 of the eight minutes spent on fishing in shilo you'll get 101k-116k xp per hour.

 

Of course, this is quite far from AFK that way.

Ah, well, there you go, that'll be the best way then.