Don't like either of them really. The Luigi one doesn't have very good composition, and as Soa said, don't put C4D's in random places. The smudging looks a bit generic too - remember that one of the fundamental techniques of smudging is slight movements of the wrist. DON'T ADD TEXT! As for the stock, it's probably the better of the two, slightly better composition, though I don't like the brushing on the guy's back. Though there is alright contrast in the tag. Maybe use a few adjustments on your tags; especially the Luigi one.