Amazing graphics will sell the game, but the gameplay and community will make the review. That seems to be the old arguement for the Runescape graphics but seeing as the graphics arent the greatest, and the gameplay and community are going downhill, Updating graphics are probably Jagex's last hope for grabbing some better gamers. This is my first and only MMO so I can't say much with compairing, but i'm sure there will be plenty word of mouth advertising to keep Runescape going for quite sometime.