Proof? Ok then, let's go by your own figures. Whip hits 40's and Godsword hits lets assume a 50. By calculating the 2-3 ratio difference in speeds we see they hit similar damage but the whip wins slightly. The godsword is now at 100 damage to the Whips 120. Now assume you will swap to a dds to spec. And going by averages you will hit perhaps 30 damage a spec. That makes the dds/whip hit a total of 240 damage in a total of 7 hits. Lets assume 8 hits as you need to change to the Dagger which also takes around one hit to do(Even if you do it correctly and don't lose a spec from accidently missclicking spec bar which is a common occurence). The GodSword has had 2 hits in same time you've used the Whip. Now you are probably going to use the spec. Sara would be used now as you'll be lowered health and arma for the extra damage. Armadyl maxes I believe a 90. But that number is unrealistic so we shall assume a moe regular occurence such as between 65-75. The GodSword will swing 2.5 times in the time it takes to use all of your Dds specials, and assume you spec twice will hit 130-150 damage, plus another 25 from half a normal swing. This makes the GodSwords total damage 255-275. The whip dds combo has hit 240 damage. Now we realise these are all just averages, however, if we look at the weapons involved we notice that purely based on bonus's of course, the GodSword will almost ALWAYS hit more higher and constant then the whip. Assuming this we see that the GodSword in a typical combat situation will win out against the whip every time. Now as you can see, I've based all of this information on your averages, and even if we lower the GodSwords max hit a bit it'll still win out agaisnt a whip. Assume GodSword only hits 45 damage, making the total 240.5-260.5. The Godsword is still the superior weapon. Even if we use for example a Bandos Godsword, which is cheap by most standards these days seeing as everyone makes money easily. It's got one special and its special maxes a 65 normally. Mask raises it by 15% making this hit a 74 at MOST. We'll assume it only hits realistically, which is around 60-65, so we shall say 63. It hits normally which we have assessed at firstly 50, making its 2.5 hits (following the dds's steps) 50-63-25. This makes the Bandos Godsword hit 138 damage at same rate of a dds hitting 120, making the GodSword hit a total of 138 damage. This is, its true, 2 below the whip and Dds combo. However, this method requires a one click step instead of clicking the Dagger, then clicking spec 4 times while being attacked by Kril and his minions. So even though the Godsword MIGHT hit 2 less overall, its far more efficient to use. This method enables us to be able to focus entirely on eating and potting at appropriate times. Now we can move onto the Saradomin Godsword and the Zamorak Godsword. Both of these have a max of around 59-60 off task. So on task they max 67.55 as a maximum hit. This appears unrealistic however, and really they would probably hit around 50 like they would non spec. Assuming they hit same rate as a dds, they will hit 50-50-25. This takes the Total damage done by the Zammy and Sara Godsword to 225. Which is 15 below that of a whip. However, Zamorak's special freeze Kril, which gives you I'm not 100% on this but I believe 20? Seconds immunity to all his hits except magic. This could save your life if you need to eat rapidly, or lag slightly. So assume we eat 3 times in that spec. We hit 15 less then with a whip but potentially heal 60 hp as well, giving it slightly more efficiency then the Whip/Dds. Now lets look at the Saradomin Godsword. It speced twice, hitting a 50 each time. These specs healed us for 50 damage total, and 25 prayer. This Godsword is also more efficient then a whip, as it saves food and heals prayer, which is a critical point of Kril, as he drains prayer.

 

 

 

Thus looking at this huge wall of text, we see that EVERY GodSword is more efficient then the whip/dds, and we also see that, if you have the money for it, the Armadyl GodSword is far superior to the whip method. And remember, with your GodSwords theres no need to be pushing tabs everywhere, enabling you to safely keep eating while using your specials, instead of relying on a peaceful bout so you can click spec. If you REALLY want I could probably get a video of a GodSword method, however, we would need the exact same stats, gear, invents and pots as the other to control all outside interference. Then we would have to test it repeatedly to get an average, as some days Kril will destroy you randomly, and sometimes he will barely even hit you, as most of us know. Based purely on statistics however, it appears godswords completely outshine the whip/dds combo.

 

Good lord that took a long time to write Lol. :geek:

 

Attack- Wall of text- lvl398

You must be mistaken Gong, that's not level 398!

 

 

 

I couldn't deal with him (Pro Melee=SirHemen): so it must be over level 650!

 

 

 

I can take 2-3 zamorak boss (lvl 650) each trip! But that wall of text, was hard :oops:

10/10 for trying so hard once again

 

2/10 for the actual content.

 

 

 

For trying so hard "again"? What you mean by that.

 

 

 

As for my achievement, i am proud of achieving it.

 

 

 

just google zammy gwd and find a guide or look at one someone has posted in the AOW

 

and you wouldn't of had to write this crap.

 

 

 

but still, good work i guess

 

 

 

cbf to rate / 10

 

 

 

My theory and achievement is crap? Thanks for those words.

 

 

 

I don't need a guide about Zamorak. I consider myself Pro at GWD.

 

 

 

I have tried SGS: and it's healing ability and prayer restore did well but that did not stop Kril from Raging you.

 

 

 

For all Gs's: when killing the sergeants, it made you kill them slowly which then lead to not much time to prepare for next respawn of boss.

 

 

 

I have used SGS and Whip, and believe me: the big difference in them was not much. But GS was bad for sergeants. If i am wrong: feel free to prove me wrong

 

 

 

Best godswords are: Bandos and Arma, the other two does not do much to affect your trip.

 

 

 

BandosGodSword: 19-21m= Great GS for Zamorak.

 

 

 

AGS= Just as great as BGS, but it cost 60m...i doubt many people can afford it.

 

 

 

That arguments not particularly valid about the sergants. Hell I'm guessing your over my (pitiful melee 88att 95str 85def) stats, I have zero problem ever with dropping the sergants after I've killed Kri'l. However I don't kill him on task, rather with a Neiz helm, so if your having a problem I'm guessing its due to your helm not giving you any usable bonuses? Or your just got plain unlucky.

So where's the achievement?

 

0/10.

So where's the achievement?

 

0/10.

 

 

 

I didn't achieve anything, but my theory came true and i take it as a achievement :P

 

 

 

Shame that you give me 0/10, but i guess drop pictures is what people like nowdays eh?

So where's the achievement?

 

0/10.

 

 

 

I didn't achieve anything, but my theory came true and i take it as a achievement :P

 

 

 

Shame that you give me 0/10, but i guess drop pictures is what people like nowdays eh?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It's Skully, if your not in his gaggle of self proclaimed "Dag King Pro's" you get a 0/10 for everything.

So where's the achievement?

 

0/10.

 

 

 

I didn't achieve anything, but my theory came true and i take it as a achievement :P

 

 

 

Shame that you give me 0/10, but i guess drop pictures is what people like nowdays eh?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It's Skully, if your not in his gaggle of self proclaimed "Dag King Pro's" you get a 0/10 for everything.

 

 

 

Couldn't care less about he is, but thanks for that lol :P