Well, I was designing a Card for my own Personal Credit Card and so I was geting some visa logos etc and making up cards in Photoshop to see what logo came out best for my own card.

 

 

 

I saw someone who made some of WoW ones (I hate that game) that they did for fun so I thought Rs should get some!

 

 

 

Also note some of these pics are from Rs itself so its only fair thats why peoples names and positions are on the card. Example: The Dwarf is a concept design by Mod GG

 

 

 

And yes the numbers and Expiry dates of these cards are fake...

 

 

 

Open to comments Negative/Positive :)

 

 

 

 

Haha, nice concept there ;)

 

Can't really see any flaws in it, other than the corners being straight.

 

 

 

Although, I'm pretty sure you will be beaten up if someone sees you with this :lol:

Lol, I just noticed the corners too. Think I used Bevel too much

 

Although, I'm pretty sure you will be beaten up if someone sees you with this

 

 

 

Bring them to school, and try buy your lunch with it?

Other than a crappy bevel and some lens flares what exactly did you do? :/

Other than a crappy bevel and some lens flares what exactly did you do? :/

 

 

 

You seem to know photoshop quite well, so why are you asking me...? You can see it

Really, don't use any of Photoshop's built in effects (Drop shadow/inner shadow, bevel and emboss, etc.), makes them just.. worse. :shame:

Really, don't use any of Photoshop's built in effects (Drop shadow/inner shadow, bevel and emboss, etc.), makes them just.. worse. :shame:

 

 

 

The only things relly Beveled are the card numbers like a real one. Visa logo to make it darker. I think my laptops brightness is different to your guys considerably as to why it might look worser

 

You seem to know photoshop quite well, so why are you asking me...? You can see it

 

 

 

It's called a rhetorical question ;)

 

 

 

I really don't know what to say about them. It's a nice concept, I'll give you that, but you just didn't execute it as well as it could have been. You're choice of effects is poor, you shouldn't need to use filters for EVERYTHING. I'd like to say something good about it but there isn't anything. All I can do is point out the flaws and ways you can fix it. An effective way is to read tutorials and to keep practising ;)

 

You seem to know photoshop quite well, so why are you asking me...? You can see it

 

 

 

It's called a rhetorical question ;)

 

 

 

I really don't know what to say about them. It's a nice concept, I'll give you that, but you just didn't execute it as well as it could have been. You're choice of effects is poor, you shouldn't need to use filters for EVERYTHING. I'd like to say something good about it but there isn't anything. All I can do is point out the flaws and ways you can fix it. An effective way is to read tutorials and to keep practising ;)

 

 

 

:) I know he was being Rhetorical, probably gave a smartass comment because I said I don't like WoW.

 

 

 

I am a web designer these cards took less than 5mins each to make. I think everyones thinking I should do something "Deviant Art" style, something I don't really have time for as I use a laptop only.

 

 

 

I'll see what I can come up with next time when I have the time Cheers :)

probably gave a smartass comment because I said I don't like WoW.

 

 

 

I gave a smartass comment because they suck. I didn't even read the comment about WoW.

i dont believe your a web designer. If you were, a good one anyways, these would be better than they are even for 5 mins.

Believe what you want, I'm not convincing idiots. Didn't know people put stuff they created for fun here to be judged by idiots who have nothing better to do everyday than put people down? Geez its only 5mins - 10 mins each because im new to CS3 Suite and were done during my break times. I'm not getting paid for these

 

 

 

Sorry they suck so bad, How about making a few whichever way you want? I'll be glad to make yours look like crap because I'll GLADY take time off work and create something to make yours a pitiful excuse to give such attacks. And bet you did read the part about Wow and said that, or your just one of those idiots who lurk in forums attacking everyone and saying "fail"

Lmao, even i could do better than those in 5 - 10 mins. and i havnt touched photoshop in a couple months.

 

 

 

You can call me an idiot, as i dont care. But the fact your callin Nadril an idiot is just funny. as he would do circles around you in most editing programs

Enough with the lame attacks.

 

 

 

Just put your money where your mouth is and stop giving crap to people

 

Just put your money where your mouth is

 

I would like to see this :)

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Stone- ... 2-23320164

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Neo-World-70111373

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Elgard ... s-24532476

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Carpe-Diem-23954133

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/The-in ... m-23578969

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Viking ... t-24209316

 

 

 

[hide=][/hide]

 

 

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Firehy ... 3-39819784

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Forest-2-of-3-39819717

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Nothin ... 3-39819608

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Norman ... d-23245946

 

 

 

http://nadril.deviantart.com/art/Planet ... t-17311448

 

 

 

[hide=]

 

 

[/hide]

 

 

 

[hide=]

 

[/hide]

COUGH COUGH OWNED COUGH COUGH

 

Just put your money where your mouth is

 

I would like to see this :)

 

 

 

Me too. I'll join in and own with GIMP.

Let's just drop it. The skill level of the person that is giving criticism shouldn't determine whether they have the right to voice their opinion on a piece of art or not. If you got a comment from someone that you don't deem knowledgeable enough to be taken seriously or just stupid, then just ignore it, but don't let it escalate into a flame war or pointless "See, I'm a much better artist than you! Owned!" thing, even if you and many other people honestly think you are indeed much more skilled than the OP. If you're really such a good artist, then have the decency to somewhat keep that to yourself when you're not showing artwork.

 

 

 

Not aimed at one of you guys specifically.

 

 

 

EDIT: Oh, and @the OP, don't put "Open to all comments" in your title when you obviously aren't.

Let's all calm down and get back to constructive criticism regarding the pieces, eh? :P

 

 

 

Strife_3e, if you encounter a comment you think is not constructive, then don't reply to it, as it will only ever trigger what just happened. ;)

Well said, Kermit.

Sorry I missed this war... but I have to agree with yaff's Comment:

You can call me an idiot, as i dont care. But the fact your callin Nadril an idiot is just funny. as he would do circles around you in most editing programs

(BTW Nadril I gave up my little feud against you.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Now to the criticism...

 

They are crap. Nothing to them. It looks like a paint (Copy, Paste) job.

Finally some people with common sense!, I was open to all comments but not 'attacks' like this is some contest thread? I made something for fun of the game and saw this forum for "fan art" and put it here. Instead some [developmentally delayed]s came and start going on "I think i'm better at this than you, you don't deserve to be here" Saying something such as "Their not that great, or they are terrible is a comment on how to improve on something that takes less than 10minutes. It is so simple to say something like that instead of having the same damn moral as stealing from a charity for orphans?

 

 

 

Now for the [developmentally delayed]s who don't seem to understand the wording of what I said earlier: Do better = Make a card IN Photoshop not something like 3D Max Studio Etc that anyone can make and put up let alone with comments on those pics saying "1hr 33mins to do" when these were not even a fraction of that time taken. Let alone something pre-made to gloat over

 

 

 

I Fail for once, that's to see how some pics that are so plain and not even done in photoshop "Own" me.

 

 

 

I am more experienced with the Adobe suite of programs. Congrats on you if you do Graphic design for how many years with 3D programs etc.

 

 

 

I'm open for some friendly competition like someone said earlier. But jesus Christ Tip.it's community really sucks this bad after all these years now???

 

 

 

Like I said: ENOUGH of the crappy attacks, lets have a fun competition?

I'm going to drop this.

 

 

 

 

 

And my advice for your cards? Less Photoshop filters, more original work. It's hard to comment and critique something when 90% of it is made up of lens flares and runescape pictures, with maybe a gradient in the background if you want to get really high tech. There is nothing short of me telling you how to make something from scratch which I am not about to do. The problem with your fan made credit cards is that just simply taking some runescape images and putting filters on it. If you look at real credit cards which are based off of games they are more about original artwork.

 

 

 

for example,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

They focus around minimalism. The problem is that if you're doing something fanmade it's hard for it to be considered your own artwork because, well, it isn't.

 

 

 

And I can't participate in your silly little challenge here. I have real work to do for both my finals coming out, for my portfolio page I need to finish and the 3D model I need to finish for class. (I study this for a living, by the way) I've not got the time to argue over petty squables. I gave you my opinion already, either ignore it and continue on doing whatever you want or think about it. It's your choice, it doesn't effect me. However don't expect to post here with 5 minute made fan art and get a positive response, it doesn't happen and it won't happen.