As long as Jad is not fully healed when you kill the healers, they will not respawn. @ OP: If you want to melee the Fight Caves, try: FSH Glory/Fury SW Cape/other Cape Bandos / Proselyte Hauberk+V Skirt Rapier/Whip Dragon Defender Barrows Gloves Dragon Boots Zerker Ring/Explorer's Ring 4/none Inventory: 3 Super Sets (- Super Defence) 6 Brews 3 Super Restores EE/EEE/Claws or both if you have Rest P Pots As soon as Jad spawns, find him and Rapier him till half health, then Claw Spec him. If he doesn't get KOed, continue to stab him. :P As for Protection Prayers, always switch to Protect Melee after he uses his Mage/Range attacks.