xcowx

Process for buying 1k hides, tanning, and crafting all 1k hides: about 45-75 minutes.(Approx.) Doing 1k your way: 2 hours+....(Correct me please) Bottomline: EVEN if you DIDN'T have 100k to buy hides. You could do in less time making money from fishing, wc, etc. then doing the 1st process I listed and still be at less time..The guide itself was really good with pictures, explanations, etc. But before making a guide you need to think about the use and for that i'll give you a 5/10. (TIP: Capitalize your title,I guarantee you'll have more views just by capitalizing. It looks so much more neat and looks so much more like you know what you're talking about)

That is all pointless spam in my opinion. Jagex summed all that up on the highscore list in less than 2 sentences. Unstead you posted this in a quite pointless, poorly written paragraph. THIS ISN'T EVEN A GUIDE. Please refer to a guide making thread. :-k

Alright, point taken. Your guide doesn't have unusual items to merchant which is understandable due to the fact that F2p items are very limited, but the layout is very original and I like it. I put some of it to use and made about 200k in 1 and half hours using 3 million in cash ;).(While using the methods I found you had create/influenced the most.) Not bad. I'm sure I could've made more, but for a person who has rarely ever merchanted, as myself to make 200k really has motivated me somewhat :D. I Revise my rating to a 8.25/10.

7.5/10 You need to make the read feel like it is something they can accomplish and with not a ton of time invested in it. This guide I felt was more of a "I did it, you can do it, it SHOULD work" kind of guide. Not saying that what you wrote but that's a little bit of the impression I got. But you get a lot of points for presentation, grammar, and useful tips.

After lookin' this guide through i'd say definitely one of the BEST guides I've ever seen. I can tell you spent time on this for the sake of helping people, not just for the popularity and people posting on your thread. Very well written, I am impressed. I'm gonn work on my pure now :P.

I give this guide 0/10...i'm sorry but you broke the rules in one of your methods, no pics, short, and tbh, you copied most of the material in this guide. If you wouldn't have broken rules, i would've given 2/10 for effort. Did you know that by creating accounts to drop trade, YOU not only cost Jagex money for every time you take up memory space on their servers every time you make a new account, YOU are breaking the rules and I will not tolerate that. Do you know why Jagex offers a free version of the game??! Well, it's because they get ads to help pay for it. But every time idiots like you do stuff like making accounts for Stronghold of Security then drop-trading cash, IT RUINS THE CHANCES FOR OTHER HONEST PLAYERS. Do you see what you've done??? Now, I suggest you edit this real quick before I get even more mad. That's all I have to say.

Hey, It helps even if all of it is not in place! I am going to save this pic if ya dun't mind :P. Good Job.