storm39

100% support. I'm sick of the melee-ers having an unfair advantage over us f2p mages.

How? We had easily 25x more people than the other fansites. You can't win against an army that big, it's impossible. You've never seen the movie "300" then have you? It was mostly the lack of recruiting on other fansites and barely showing up that caused us to win :| In real life, yes. But in RuneScape, you have no chance at all. 1,999 level 3s vs. 1 lvl 138 He's out numbers 2000x, but the lvl 138 would win. Unless they're mage and/or range pures :P . However, most of our people were around lv. 60-70, with a few 30s, 40s, 50s, and 70+ here and there from what I remember. The enemy forces that we fought totaled to around 50. They didn't stand a chance.

In my opinion, it wasn't the leadership that caused the problems, but rather the traitors and lack of competition. Like Ximigda said, what can you expect with that many people? And Sals really needs to get over it. Even if they made it, they would have been greeted by a sea of green capes. The whole "assassin" thing was probably a load of BS as well.

As a f2p-er, I'd be more than happy with claws, spears, halberds, and crossbows. I'd like to see some decent mage gear rather than dragon gear as well. Not some overpriced degrading crap from a minigame either.

Although it can be fun, I'm in it for the cash. Unless it's a raid on a town, I'm always in it for profit. That's why I never spent GP on supplies for Clan Wars.

Only for severe things. I usually only report for item/password scamming, and I reported autoers back in the days of free trade.

I rarely do it, since in my opinion, it's something that immature people do to make them feel better about themselves. I'll sometimes call someone that if they do something incredibly cheap, unfair, etc.(cheap tactic, scamming, etc).

Varrock. It's there that I started my mage career, smithing career, mining career, PKing career, and it's my favorite town in general.

We already have Reaper, Skeleton, and Pumpkin items. We need something original. I'd like the idea of Vampire clothes (or at least a cape). Demon items are also a good idea.

The war itself was ok, but the raids afterwords were AWESOME!!! We need more raid events. Maybe we can even try to take over an entire world. It's a possibility if we can gather that many people.

Also, I'd like a different area of the wildy to fight in next time. The battlefield was rather boring...

@ your first and second points: DID YOU ACTUALLY READ THE FIRST POST? The tracks are above ground level (like, in the sky.) And there ARE random events. Really. I read the post. I just think that trains being in the sky would seem a bit... odd. Trains being underground would make more sense. I was also simply suggestions on random events.

I have a few ideas to improve this. 1. Trains should be underground. If they're underground, tracks won't have to be shown anywhere aside from the stations. This will solve just about every map problem(people getting hit by trains, etc.). 2. Random events on trains. Every now and then, bandits could hide out on the trains, and strike in the middle of a ride. Players would have to fend them off. To make sure that low level players are safe, they would go after high level players first. Instead of killing you, they would attack you until you're at 1 hp, them steal a few of your items(nothing over a certain amount, though, and each bandit would only take one). If a player manages to kill one, they would get the drop. Of course, there would have to be limits to make RWT impossible. This is just a basic concept. Also, to the people that complain that smithing is required... Woodcutting is required for firemaking(unless you buy logs). Mining is required for Smithing(unless you buy ores). I don't see people complaining about either of those. You'd still be able to buy parts from other players. To the people that think that it will drive people away from becomming members... Jagex is giving f2p the most boring experience possible. All that does is make f2p players think that members is just as boring, just with a bigger world and more items. Instead something like this would make f2p players think something like "This is amazing! And I hear that members get all kinds of this stuff!" Just something to consider...

I support this fully. This would be a great skill for higher level f2p players.

It has next to no use in f2p. It's just a waste of money IMO. We may as well throw GP on the ground and burn it... wait, we practically are. Firemaking should have some use beyond burning logs and lighting funeral pyres, especially on f2p. The fireworks idea is a great one. Crafters can make fireworks, and firemakers can burn them.