My thoughts exactly. Jagex can take down YouTube videos for copyright claims, but can't get people selling their property for profit? O_O First I'd like to say, they already have the back up domain ready. They have had their customers aware of this dispute between them and Jagex for ages. Not only that, but Jagex has not yet won the case. Their customers know that as soon, if at all, Jagex takes control of the domain, which domain the company will change to. It will not halt that company for more then 10 minutes. Secondly, the company isn't selling property that isn't theirs. They're selling their time and their resources that it took to collect the gold and items. You're technically hiring them and their resources to play RuneScape. Hell, until eBay didn't want it, people could say, "Selling funny joke - Free RuneScape account included!" Loophole. This won't phase G4RS at all. Well, I'm no lawyer, but I don't see your point. If you were hiring them to train your account or for a bot, you could say that...but account and all of its items are property to Jagex, no matter how much time you put into that. You're selling the account or the gold, you're selling Jagex's property. And that's it. I still don't see why Jagex bothers to sue for copyright infringement regarding the domain name - it's worse than useless. They have a bad chance of winning, in any case it will cost them money for lawyers etc., and the RWTers can just switch to another domain which increases their reputation as they can claim "Jagex can't touch us" basically. It's simple. Say I decided to RWT. I could just as easily say that I'm not paying them for the gold, but for their time in collecting it. I'm paying them for the 100s of hours it took to collect that 1000M for me, not for the gold itself. I'm also paying for the computers, the bot software, and all the other resources they need upkept to collect that gold. I'm paying them for the time that they're saving me. Just like the joke example, I'm paying them for the service, which just happens to result in my free 1000M. Jagex could not dispute this claim. And to the terms of use arguments... Checking a little box stating that you've read and agree to a game's terms of use is not legally binding. The most that could come of breaking them is that your rights/privleges in that game be taken away.