1) was this necessary? Nope. Just nerfing mummies, perhaps, but I see it in a similar light to the way I see certain recent piracy issues. To put it simply, if there's a problem with people doing too much of something you don't want them to, the solution isn't to just try and make them stop; it's to have them want to stop. Make training things like RC more amusing, and I'm not talking about more little once-per-week things. Give people a reason to not hoard effigies, instead of just making it impossible. 2) are effigies in the spirit of the game? In my opinion? Yes. They work well, reduce grinding at high levels, and get players to work together (whenever the stupid time limit is up). 3) do you agree with the way jagex implemented their nerf? As usual, no. See the response to #1 if you really want to know more.