Toxicologist

Look... if people introduced horses for jousting, pretty soon everyone would want horses for transport as well, since JAGeX implemented horses, why not use them for their main use: transport? No. No way. Summary: Rating of 1 - 10 Horse Jousting: 1

Nobody ever PMs me after first contact if I don't reply back to them... that includes beggars as well...

You posted a suggestion to discourage a suggestion... yeah. Smart move.

ROLF!!!!!!!!!! And yeah, I'd just go around performing autopsies (on live humans), maybe useing painful, slow-acting poisons as a substitute for anesthetic. They can't put me in prison anyway, because I can just teleport (and teleother my victim with me).

The point is, most of those ideas either sound stupid, or are excessive.

Well I suppose the double spear won't be too akward, considering JAGeX just implemented the "Bow-sword"...

Well, considering "Cook X" and such are official autos, I don't see why implementing Hotkeys would be considered "illegal autoing". Also, when i first thought of this idea I intended it to become for combat purposes... I didn't intend it to become a skill auto, although I don't see any wrong in that. And by the way, Hotkeys don't allow you to automine or autowoodcut or autofish and such, so why is it considered autoing? Autoing is doing something without you being there to control it, like AFK training or botting.

Actually, I just got an idea: Make an extension to Zanaris: A large forest completely composed of Magic Trees. It is a restricted forest which requires a certain woodcutting level to enter. There's your Woodcutting Guild.

The problem with a Woodcutting Guild is that it should be very big (like someone said before, a restricted forest), as you don't see a bunch of wierd people standing around in a building hacking away at trees. So the problem: Where do you find such a big land to create a WC Guild in?

I feel this idea is rather ingenious, and I support it. It would give people another reason to complete quests.

You have the wrong idea about Guthix. Sure Guthix cares about Balance, but he is not neutral: he does interfere. First: He interfered during the God Wars, When Saradomin and Zamorak are raging battles against each other. Guthix rose and stopped them, forcing them to sign a treaty to not interfere directly with the affairs of mortals. If Guthix didn't stop the War, Pompous Saradomin and Sarcastic Zamorak would've torn the world asunder with their Ignorance. Second: The sword Silverlight (and Darklight, in a manner of speaking) was created by Guthix to combat the demon Delrith, who he deems powerful enough to upset the balance. Therefore he created the sword to stop the evil. These are just a few of the more well-known example of Guthix interfering with the world. I might also add that the Runescape as we know it was created by Guthix.

*Thumbs Up* To idea and editing.

God cannons sound extremely stupid. The "Mange Bow" as you call it... I would assume that to be the same as a Crystal Bow, or maybe a Magic Bow. Personally I think it is uneccessary (as it is similar to the above), and the name is extremely unoriginal. The double spear... I don't know what to say about that, except it seems rather excessive. Besides, there are no weapons with daggers at each side of the end of a pole... only double axes or something, and that's basically the same as a halbeard. Monks don't go into battle. The name needs to be refined. It could be just a "Monk's Staff" or a "Sheperd's Staff" or something. Also, I believe you could just substitute the God Staves for this. Summary: Scale of 1 - 10 God Cannons: 1 Mange Bow: 3 Double Spear: 4 Monk Staff: 6

Monks don't wear capes. They aren't the type to go out into public and start rushing at people. As for a Monk's Staff, monks already have weapons: maces. You could of course make Clerical Staves, But personally I think the God Staves can substitute for that. Perhaps give them a prayer bonus too?

Yay! Let us assimilate RS into World of Warcraft! Well, not exactly; but... Horaay! The uncountable-th topic on RS3!!! Now lets make RSVR (Runescape Virtual Reality)! 100 Years later... JAGeX: Hellow players! We are going to release the new RSVR13 to the public as beta phrase! Come join the fun now!

LOL!

How on Earth can you find Guthix stupid? Saradomin and Zamorak maybe, but Guthix?

For one thing, what is wrong with autoing? It makes the game less tedious doesn't it? And besides, it doesn't really save much time; just makes it less tedious. I hope this isn't getting into a "RS2 Product" discussion... As for autocast, I have explained that before. With hotkey auto it happens like this: R Click R Click R Click R Click... like you said. With staff auto it is this: Click. End of story. There is still a great difference. And considering mages are the only class that can't autocast some of their attacks properly, I think it wouldn't make much difference.

This idea is a definite no. I have stated the reason before, I won't state it again.

He does. Personally, I think Saradomin is a pompus, self-righteous old man.

Nice idea. I always feel my head is too exposed when I wear Monk's robes.

... might as well make explosive potions are throwable ranging weapon... As for bleeding, don't you bleed more if somone hacks at you with a sword, rather than having small peices of metal stuck in your body?

20 seconds with Ice Barrage, actually.

Alright then... sorry for being offensive, I kind of lost myself there. For points of changing (if that's what you want), lessen the quest reward and the experience reward because no other quest gives that much reward, and thus doing so may unbalance the Runescape economy and PK system and such... its the difference between throwing a few small stones at a person and having him catch it, and suddenly throw a huge rock and crush him under it. Entrana, like many have said before; is populated by peaceful monks who wish to have nothing to do with the rest of the world, and they certainly don't want hot-blooded heroes stampeding around their peaceful island; regardless of their religon and such. They are peaceful and wish for no trouble. And I have sort of forgotten what you said about all those swords ideas... lol.

I never betted on the triangle. I'm talking about things like Ancient Magicks, Entangle, and the fact warriors have negative magic bonus. This is fact, and Runescape is not a tactics game: it is a game of luck and power, not skill. Generally, mages beat warriors. As for melee in dragonhide armour, a lucky freeze will stop the warrior in his/tracks. A warrior unable to move is a warrior dead. Dragonhide, no matter how resistant, is not immune to a mage's attack. But on topic: So I am against this idea too.