youmakemesik

Text on first sig stands out (too contrasty), taking away from the dark mood and 'feel' of the sig. Text on second sig is very bad. Stands outs and well, is gernerall just quite poor... The 'flame' on the second sig has VERY rough/sketchy linework and doesn't really fit in with the sig... Over all, they're 'ok', but eh, pretty average overall...

Yeh he did... Just look at the stance/posture of the character, and the placement of his/her limbs and items...

Simple Marking Sheet- Foreground Linework: + 2 Background Linework: + 1 Foreground Shading/Texturing: + 2 Background Shading/Texturing: + 1 Perspective/Concept/Creativity: + 1.5 Total: + 7.5 Comments: Foreground is very nice, has some nice detail there, but as you can probably see, your background needs a bit of work... The ocean and sky are a bit plain (only wave-lines and 'clouds'), and your horizon line is a bit tooo straight ;) I like the scenery/concept of the sig. Um, why is the toip of the castle (receiving most light) the darkest? Or did they like use a different brick colour there or something... Also, the shading on your character is a bit strangee... The right side of the shirt is darkest, whereas the left side of the pants are darkest... Strange? Overall, quite good, looks pretty nice...

Don't you mean work on the outline of the ranger on the first one? Anyway, I'm not a big fan of the red contrasting very deeply with the grey (in the first sig) but I like the shading/prespective (in the second one).

2.10... Just too boring and a dull mood to it...

Average Rating: 4/10 First sig bonus: +2 Subtraction of using images: -2 Final Rating: 4/10 Comment: Quite bad, too busy (2nd), bad colour choice, no effects/techniques/talent shown or used.

Erm, have you got I-Can't-Stop-Wanting-Things-To-Be-So-Pretty-Like-Bunnies-And-Squirrels-And-Oh-The-Colour-Pink-Syndrome or something? Cuase you're starting to freak me out...

My friend (not really, I just like saying that), you are an idiot... Please, "how was I crying like a little girl"? You mean, why I was flaming you for being narrow-minded, idiotic and greedy? You're pathetic... You say you lowered your price (which is pretty much bribery), because everyone was being greedy??? Well... If you havn't realised, Dreamlove MADE the competition, and she'll pay what she wants... Don't take away from the competition and prize-money, with an excuse that, "everyone is being greedy"... Oh and, if you havn't noticed, I"M NOT EVEN IN THIS COMPETITION! I'm speaking on behalf of the others, keeping in mind some incidents that have happened in the past... Oh and um, if you think the price should be lowered, how bout you leave, seeing as Dream Love wants it this way... If the payer is ok with it, why arn't you... :roll: Again, what you are doing is bribery (to a certain extent), and takes away from everyone else's chances of winning (not that you stand a chance atm)... EDIT: Sry for spamming Dreamlove, couldn't resist retalliating...

Firstly, the reason I had the angry attitude in my previous post, was cause I just read your extremely stupid thread about clothes :roll: :lol: Now, it's still very hard to create you (with detail), surrounded by trees (not so much detail), and a rune guy (with detail), and maybe a few extras, all in a 3D sig... Btw, 30k is very low for a price :wink:

Worst thread ever...

^Sorry, I forgot... what was the point of that comment again? Now, NeanderSlave, I got nothing against you, and don't say I'm being mean, cause I'm not, but seriously... Read this form and you'll understand... What is teh sig?: The sig is nothing but a part of a screenshot, beside a very boring and plain box of one colour, with bad text in it... What are any special effects or techniques in the sig: Nothing special, nothing that stands out, nothing that requires skill... Skills or knowledge required to make sig: Must have knowledge of how to crop (EASY) , must know how to insert a text-box (EASY) , and must know how to fill a box with paint-bucket (EASY) ... See what I mean? I know I'm being a bit blunt with my criticism, but seriously, I'm trying to be as honest as I can, that sig required no skill... Next time, maybe try to actually 'Make' the sig? What I mean is, try actually making some abstract-type effects and graphics, pixel sigs that you actually created pixel by pixel, hand drawings scanned onto the computer, etc, etc... Not some 5 second thing you made in paint...

Wow! 30k! Amazing :roll: Oh and btw, how the hell is someone supposed to make all that into a sig and add a lot of detail, if this sig is not to be pixel :roll: They gonna make all that in 3D? I doubt it... Especially for 30k...

NEVER do that again... Really pisses me off when people take hours to amke sigs expecting a high pay such as 500k or 1 mil, and then are ripped off by some idiot coming forward and telling the buyer that he/she will sell for much cheaper, and therefore, bringing down the prize of, and the meaning of the word, competition... Sry if I came across as flaming, just hate when people do that :wink:

Are you joking? What, you think you people are gonna go make sigs that take hours, and sometimes days to make, just cause you wanna find the 'prettiest' one?!? This is funny... I really hope you meant, "I just would like to see who can copy and paste the 'prettiest' image made by someone on this site"...

For the sig: 3/10. For the theme: 10/10 :D

Yay! :D Lol, you're still using my avvy :lol:

What the... I don't get the title :? :? :? :? :?

Yup, best evidence wins unfortunately :? Wthether you lie, or speak the truth, you now depend on minni_me to support some evidence on your behalf... I await his post... Btw, I love my court idea too! :lol:

As I said in my earlier post (quoted above), I'm not 100 % positive of the rip, no1 is, but it is very probable that you did rip it, and THAT is why I'm siding with Mr. X... See, the problem is, whether you ripped it or not, it looks VERY VERY similar (even the placement of fingers on the hand), and so we are believing that Mr. X has the strongest piece of evidence so far... I, and everyone else, has no proof that's ABSOLUTELY correct, but they're so dam close that we are forced to believe Mr.x's point of view... Sry if I'm incorret, and if you did rip it, like jab said, I don't know why you did... Cause you were developing very finely and you were fairly established already... Goodluck in winning your case tho (to both Mr.x and LG)... P.S. There should be a court for hte Media Board, and you'd trial everyone there... Mod's could be judges/juries and everyone else would be the audience/eye-witnesses/etc... You could hire lawyers to gather up evidence for you (using zoom and stuff), and the lawyer would do the speeches as you sit back and say "I'm innocent", and the lawyers could be payed in RS... Crazy idea, but sounds kinda fun to dream about... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Dang, I don't know what to think now :? I like both your artworks (Mr.x being a pro pixel'er, and Lord Gabriel being a very impressive new-commer), but I wasn't sure wat to think... So I had a look at the evidence... I highlighted the features I thought were either ripped or very suspiscious, and looked at them under a microscope, of 30x ... And well, they look VERY similiar... Now, if only the outlines were the same, I'd side with Gab here, but, even the shirt creaes on the arms are VERY similiar... So, I looked again, and tried fitting eaach arm over Mr.x's arms... They fit very well, but not perfect... I tried the head (without the hat), and they fit quite well too... Although I liked watching LG's progress, and although I enjoyed giving him CC and he was rather friendly, I'm siding with Mr.x here, as the evidence is too strong... Purple = Ripped or Suspicious Features: Very Disapointting Lord Gab (if this is true) :cry:

Oh my god. You gotta be joking. Let's see what's teh same: Party Hat (same shape and general linework)... Skirt (same outline, just slightly altered)... Position of Party Hat (sinking over eyes)... Chain Mail (linework/pattern)... Ammy (same outline and linework)... Hand Style/position (exact same position and gesture of hand)... Mouth (exactly the same)... Sword (same position/direction, just altered style/shape from original)... Shoes (same positition and shape)... Stance of character (exactly the same)... :roll: :lol: :roll: Let's see what's not teh same: Umm... Err... Uhh... yeh, umm... Err... NOTHING?! Look, this is ridiculous... EVERYTHING in the picture is the same, just altered... I don't care if the colour's different, I don't care if he has a different type of ammy, I don't care if his sword has been changed, IT IS STILL A RIP! Everything has been altered from the original to DIVERT SUSPISCION!!! Point Proven? :roll: Lol...This is really funny :lol: You've just said he might have copy-pasted, but he changed a few things... Lol, my friend, THAT IS A RIP! It's illegal (and a rip) to take someone elses work, alter it slightly (AND I MEAN SLIGHTLY), and claim it to be yours... This is honestly just stupid, try asking a mod if this is ripping, and every half-decent mod will say a definate YES. I don't mean to sound rude or anyhting, but you eyes don't matter... It's the LAW, the RULES, the REGULATIONS we follow here, that prevent us frm doing something so stupid as ripping work from others... Look, I might think it's ok to get your sig, change the text, and sell it, IN MY EYES. Does that matter? No it doesn't! Why doesn't it matter? Cause it's not up to me, it's the rules... If you don't want to obey them, you gotta get out. Don't be so naiive... Honestly, I could rip someones work, as obvious as this, and say my friend made it... DOES THAT SETTLE EVERYTHING?!?! No! It doesn't! Why? Cause System has NO HARD PROOF! If your theory was put into place, that would alow me to make millions of cash just by stealing and selling sig, claiming my friend created them.

Arn't both of those text effects done directly from tutorials :roll: Now, don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the use of tutorials, but I just think it's a bit stupid to declare yourself "good at effects", and show effects you have used direct tutorials for...

"" ""

Hm, I thought you were going because of stuck up abstracter's (which you still havn't named for me) and pathetic pixel beginners (who are trying to improve):roll: . Changed your mind have you? If you were being serious, that's a really stupid comnment... What right do you have to say, that he is going along with others just to be cool and respected? How do you know he doesn't have an opinion of his own? Oh and by-the-way, how do you know DeviantArt won't be like that? I highly doubt you've met a majority of the members there... Which I think is a really immature and unnecessary way to leave a board... Why the hell would you try and go for making more enemies just cause you're leaving... If you're gonna go cause you don't lke us or the board, just go, we don't need you so don't blame us for making you leave. Oh and by-the-way, Chicken's got a very good point: If you're gonna leave cause you're fed up with us, we're fine with that. If you feel like changing board, that's fine, don't ahve to stir things up and blame us for making you leave. If you think we're not treating you fairly, and think our work's not good enough, fine with us, just go... We don't need you around here announcing that you're leaving cause of us. Just go. Cause if you're gonna leave with a crap attitude like this, we're not even gonna think of sympathising or respecting you.