Macroer solution that might actually work!

[The Observer]

Ray, finish the Restless Ghost Quest on your skiller. It raises up prayer enough to gain a combat level.

 

 

 

P.S. How did this discussion move onto this?

[jwrm22]

a 99 wcer and nothing els trained wont match that...

[NJE03]

I'm still open on suggestions for the total level requirement. Is 500 a bit better?

 

 

 

Afterall we can't make it too low because the lower it is, the more autoers there will be.

500 seems reasonable, I would say the 700 would be good except for the skillers. At any rate I support this.

[flava0falcon]

skillers really need to do something with their lives. i really like this idea, i support.

 

 

 

I disagree with your choice of words. I am now 100% Pure Skiller. Pure Skillers do NOT have to change what they do!

 

Some people don't train prayer! Or farming! (Etc) Pure skillers have a choice on what to train, and what to do. They are human, unlike your selfish idioticy*

 

 

 

500 total level, 700 total lv, they are all unrealistic. Let's take a look at the non-members break up of skills...

 

 

 

combat_

 

Attack

 

Strength

 

Defese

 

hitpoints

 

Range

 

Mage

 

Prayer

 

 

 

....Prayer isn't a combat skill....

Prayer is a combat skill you just need like 30 lvls of prayer to level combat...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

On topic: I think 700 or 500 is too much, how about 300? because thats over 2 99s (ofcours you don't even need 1 99 to get 300 total but 1 or 2 won't do which makes it imposible for bots to not train other skills if they want to try macro system).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Also, I think lobs, coal, mith, addy, sharks and swordies should have total lvl requirement (each 1 a diffrent number since you need diffrent lvls to be able to get them).

[Pan_Nx]

I support.

[jwrm22]

No it doesn't. My skiller has 5 prayer, no combat level higher than 3 =]

Let me know what happens when you raise another prayer level..

 

 

 

I did *Hmph* still level 3

 

 

 

8 prayer = 1 combat lvl...

[flava0falcon]

RayOxide just go to a combat calculator on Tip.It and put in 99 all except prayer and you won't get 126 combat...Prayer IS a combat skill.

[brianw789]

i have to agree 700 is way to high I think that it should be more oround 400 so skillers who work on more then just wc but the macrows who only do wc would not be able to get them

 

 

 

any way I suport

[chase_cool7]

In almost every solution the only problem is skillers, im almost tempted to just say to bad the ends justify the means... almost.

[flava0falcon]

In almost every solution the only problem is skillers, im almost tempted to just say to bad the ends justify the means... almost.

I have to disagree with you skillers have the right to be members just like you.

[geesch]

i completely disagree. this is really discrimination (for a lack of a better term) against people who choose to focus on certain skills. if the minimum was 500 that would be way too much. as pointed out earlier skillers would need to have each skill at an average in the mid to high 80's. i would try to find a better solution that doesnt eliminate the possible progress of a skiller.

[flava0falcon]

i completely disagree. this is really discrimination (for a lack of a better term) against people who choose to focus on certain skills. if the minimum was 500 that would be way too much. as pointed out earlier skillers would need to have each skill at an average in the mid to high 80's. i would try to find a better solution that doesnt eliminate the possible progress of a skiller.

Actualy 150-200 is easy to get even if you don't train combat and if you know what skills to train and where you can do it in 1 day (ofcours if you don't know it might take few days but it's easy and will eliminate p2p bots...But then again there is the bigger problem of f2p bots...).

[Happysniff]

No it doesn't. My skiller has 5 prayer, no combat level higher than 3 =]

Let me know what happens when you raise another prayer level..

 

 

 

I did *Hmph* still level 3

 

 

 

Prayer DOES raise your combat level, get it to 8 or 9 and you'll see :?

[The Observer]

i completely disagree. this is really discrimination (for a lack of a better term) against people who choose to focus on certain skills. if the minimum was 500 that would be way too much. as pointed out earlier skillers would need to have each skill at an average in the mid to high 80's. i would try to find a better solution that doesnt eliminate the possible progress of a skiller.

 

 

 

500 isn't bad. Besides, it would make it so that you will have work hard to get at the yew trees. About the pure woodcutters, they will have to lose. Because Autoers are "pure woodcutters" as well.

[Guest ShadowClawe]

I strongly do not support.

 

 

 

1. Woodcutting is not the only skill that is flooded with macros.

 

 

 

2. This would confuse many new players. On Tutorial Island, a beginner wonders: "I wonder why you need 500 total level to cut yews..." Because Jagex definately won't make the tutor say, "You need a high total level to cut yews because a lot of macros woodcut yews." Then the beginner will only ask, "Whats a macro?"

 

 

 

3. This may only encourage high macroing in other possible AFK skills. Macro owners see that they need a high total level to cut their yews, so they start macroing in fishing and mining, to gain their total level.

 

 

 

Obviously this idea needs to be more thought out.

[The Observer]

I strongly do not support.

 

 

 

1. Woodcutting is not the only skill that is flooded with macros.

 

 

 

2. This would confuse many new players. On Tutorial Island, a beginner wonders: "I wonder why you need 500 total level to cut yews..." Because Jagex definately won't make the tutor say, "You need a high total level to cut yews because a lot of macros woodcut yews." Then the beginner will only ask, "Whats a macro?"

 

 

 

3. This may only encourage high macroing in other possible AFK skills. Macro owners see that they need a high total level to cut their yews, so they start macroing in fishing and mining, to gain their total level.

 

 

 

Obviously this idea needs to be more thought out.

 

 

 

They could put total level restrictions for the lobster fishing spots and stuff. Whatever gets infested with macroers will have a total level limit.

 

 

 

Like I said, it would be unpractical, but the fact is, they could have a completly simple explanation for why there needs to be a total level.

[Guest ShadowClawe]

I strongly do not support.

 

 

 

1. Woodcutting is not the only skill that is flooded with macros.

 

 

 

2. This would confuse many new players. On Tutorial Island, a beginner wonders: "I wonder why you need 500 total level to cut yews..." Because Jagex definately won't make the tutor say, "You need a high total level to cut yews because a lot of macros woodcut yews." Then the beginner will only ask, "Whats a macro?"

 

 

 

3. This may only encourage high macroing in other possible AFK skills. Macro owners see that they need a high total level to cut their yews, so they start macroing in fishing and mining, to gain their total level.

 

 

 

Obviously this idea needs to be more thought out.

 

 

 

They could put total level restrictions for the lobster fishing spots and stuff. Whatever gets infested with macroers will have a total level limit.

 

 

 

Like I said, it would be unpractical, but the fact is, they could have a completly simple explanation for why there needs to be a total level.

 

Sorry, but thats just out of this world.

 

 

 

Beginner: "I want to go fishing!"

 

Tutor: "You need a high total level."

 

Beginner: "Aww man... I want to go fishing... so let me raise my total level by woodcutting."

 

Tutor: "You need a high total level for that too."

 

Beginner: "What?! Omg fine then ill mine to raise my total level gees!"

 

Tutor: "You need a high-"

 

Beginner: "WTH is this frickin game!!!"

[The Observer]

I strongly do not support.

 

 

 

1. Woodcutting is not the only skill that is flooded with macros.

 

 

 

2. This would confuse many new players. On Tutorial Island, a beginner wonders: "I wonder why you need 500 total level to cut yews..." Because Jagex definately won't make the tutor say, "You need a high total level to cut yews because a lot of macros woodcut yews." Then the beginner will only ask, "Whats a macro?"

 

 

 

3. This may only encourage high macroing in other possible AFK skills. Macro owners see that they need a high total level to cut their yews, so they start macroing in fishing and mining, to gain their total level.

 

 

 

Obviously this idea needs to be more thought out.

 

 

 

They could put total level restrictions for the lobster fishing spots and stuff. Whatever gets infested with macroers will have a total level limit.

 

 

 

Like I said, it would be unpractical, but the fact is, they could have a completly simple explanation for why there needs to be a total level.

 

Sorry, but thats just out of this world.

 

 

 

Beginner: "I want to go fishing!"

 

Tutor: "You need a high total level."

 

Beginner: "Aww man... I want to go fishing... so let me raise my total level by woodcutting."

 

Tutor: "You need a high total level for that too."

 

Beginner: "What?! Omg fine then ill mine to raise my total level gees!"

 

Tutor: "You need a high-"

 

Beginner: "WTH is this frickin game!!!"

 

 

 

Beginners cannot fish lobsters and they cannot chop yew trees.

[Seth161991]

 

....Prayer isn't a combat skill....

 

 

 

Although this is off-topic, IT IS!...

 

 

 

Sorry for that, just had say that, but I tottlay disagree, for new free player (and some n00by, mid-level members :-w ...) and pures/skillers it's too hard to get.

[matchbookman]

prayer is a combat skill...

 

 

 

un-official definition of combat skill: A skill that when raised enough levels, results in you combat level also rising.

 

 

 

sry for that off topic bit

 

 

 

i think your idea is good but maby like 200 toatl lev, i dont think macros will go the truble to raise ether skills

 

 

 

i suport