Not Bad,

 

To high Skills what you need

 

I Support

 

 

 

Make a support list

Agreed.

i support

I support, but, that would be really difficult quest. Ah well, If it happens, I will enjoy the challenge!

I like my F2P quest better :D

As long as it could be completed by a combat level 95+ FTP player.

 

It should be fine.

 

If not it'll be imbalance.

I think that 100k for the reward for this quest is a bit too "hearty". It would be more like 25k. :roll: But otherwise, I think it is a pretty good quest for F2Pers, but a bit too easy for P2Pers. And you should think it out a bit more because that is a pretty short quest, mostly of killing. Good job though! =D>

I'd say.... hmm..... 8/10? I think it's not that hard for members, but I shudder the fact that if this were to become real, f2p rants saying the quest is wayy too over-powered. It isn't for members (We have to deal w/ GWD, Jad, Spirit Beast this month, yada yada), I think you get what i'm saying. The rewards look good though, I like the concept of 2 new battle spels, and for f2p to step up their game. Just make the xp reward, like, 30k is a skill of your choice (even members don't have a quest that gives 35k xp to all skills), 35k for everything is wayy too overpowering! F2p has good (not great, just good) training methods, and this quest would just ruin the fun of training. Imagine you(f2p), worked so hard for a high Prayer level, and, hence, along came this quest. A noob (f2p), who just barely have enough stuff to do this here quest, finishes, and had level 1 prayer before finishing. He finishes, and gets that same prayer level that you worked so hard for. Now, would that be fair? No, it wouldn't be. And like the post beore me, 100k is too much, make it 30 - 50k roughly. I personally like the quest idea, just what happens and the rewards seem a little too much for f2p. Like I said, 8/10.

100k for that easy quest? All you need is prayer...

 

 

 

35k xp for prayer???? lol (plus all other combat stats) What about Summoning?

The monsters are supposed to be members only, and the reward is overpowered. The only possible way for most nonmembers to get through is to hack RuneScape and bring back prayer potions.

This looks like a good quest idea, I support.

nice work with the quest. F2P needs a new quest. even if it is a big gap between it and dragonslayer.

 

but it does need to tie in with the history of runescape, myabe even tying it in with the delrith story??

 

the rewards are good, but instead of money, you would need to have a choice between the 3 main combat styles(like as minirouge13 said for example a melee weapon/bow, on top of the staff.

 

 

 

good start 7/10 for me. tie it in with the history and add more variety of rewards and you've got 10/10 in my books :thumbup:

good f2p quest

 

also making it easy for p2p guarantess no rants of 'nuuhhhh u took 2 much time on f2p quests nuhh'

no offense, but i think thats a pretty dumb quest with no plot... but i think a new f2p quest should be made (it prob won't tho)