rate or hate new grunge siggy

[Gehackte]

 

rate plz comment

[Rainy_Day]

Not great to be honest. It looks like a white background, with a Louigi background pasted on, then some grunge brushes used on top. Then some text. Next time, use more effects, make the render stand out more and use more of the space you have. :P

 

 

 

4/10. :/

[yaff2]

Not great to be honest. It looks like a white background, with a Louigi background pasted on, then some grunge brushes used on top. Then some text. Next time, use more effects, make the render stand out more and use more of the space you have. :P

 

 

 

4/10. :/

 

 

 

agreed, and i would get away from the whole grunge brushing anyways, they arnt that good. use abstract IMO if you are goign to brush.

[Nom]

IMO, green doesn't work well at all with grunge. Use dark greens and greys/browns if you must.

[guthix121]

I don't like how you partly left Luigi alone, and part of him you covered with the brush. If you are going to brush over him, atleast finish the job!

[terley]

Are you guys comparing this signature to his last? because I see some great improvements. You're definately getting there Gehackte, still some issues with placement, try juggling around where you want things, make sure it doesn't look overly empty or busy.

 

 

 

Luigi's much more readable but the green texturing over him is only pulling him back into the background, it would be much better if maybe only his arm faded slightly and his face was left clear so its much easier on the eyes.

 

 

 

The background is much better than on your last, a vast improvement but think of this as a piece of art on a whole, you're not just plopping an image onto a background and adding text, you're creating an entirely new image. some variation maybe?

 

 

 

keep at it you're doin great.

[Aussie_King]

I really don't like it, sorry. 2/10. I'm not so good at rating grunge sigs but I'd say maybe use darker colours.

[purfishx]

Well, IMO, better than the last by farrr.

[Gehackte]

yeah ty for the comments guys really helpfull i need some improvements on making it only the grunge is hard i willl keep on trying to make it look better:P

[Varda]

Signature tuts

 

 

 

Here, take a look on them. There are some nice signature tutorials there.

 

 

 

And I must say, rating doesn't help at all.

[amitoz]

Are you guys comparing this signature to his last? because I see some great improvements. You're definately getting there Gehackte, still some issues with placement, try juggling around where you want things, make sure it doesn't look overly empty or busy.

 

 

 

Luigi's much more readable but the green texturing over him is only pulling him back into the background, it would be much better if maybe only his arm faded slightly and his face was left clear so its much easier on the eyes.

 

 

 

The background is much better than on your last, a vast improvement but think of this as a piece of art on a whole, you're not just plopping an image onto a background and adding text, you're creating an entirely new image. some variation maybe?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

keep at it you're doin great.

 

 

 

 

 

I also see improvement.