Title pretty much says all. I need your opinions on the sigs I am going to display below. CC would be really helpful.

 

 

 

[hide=Sigs]

 

 

 

 

 

 

[/hide]

C'mon people! I need ur opinions.

Not very appealing IMO, I don't like how the smudge or w/e is just weird where it shows the faces again. IMO, 1st is the best.

You just posted this 5 minutes ago, what the hell do you expect? And don't double post.

 

 

 

However I really like the first one,

 

But not feeling the other too, maybe because I hate those stupid Chinese/Japanese cartoons.

 

 

 

First one tho 9/10

You just posted this 5 minutes ago, what the hell do you expect? And don't double post.

 

 

 

Thats what I thought...

You just posted this 5 minutes ago, what the hell do you expect? And don't double post.

 

 

 

However I really like the first one,

 

But not feeling the other too, maybe because I hate those stupid Chinese/Japanese cartoons.

 

 

 

First one tho 9/10

 

 

 

I know 3rd one looks chinese but thats Cloud from Final Fantasy lol. :lol:

Final fantasy is a Japanese game...

 

 

 

@ Sigs : They're all very flat. Needs more depth

Did you abuse filter and smudge?

The renders don't look well with the background at all. I like #1 the best because at least the render is a similar texture to the background. But #2 and #3 just aren't very attractive because they stand out from the background way too much. The backgrounds look oversharpened, whereas the renders are generally pretty smooth, so it just makes the signatures look unappealing.. whereas the first one has a render that looks pretty "grungy" to begin with, so it looks okay with the background.

Try doing something else? As far as I can tell you just took 3 renders then smeared the background :? .

Looks like you used the same tutorial for all of them. Try to do things different then repeat the same thing/effects over and over again.

 

 

 

And why the hell did you bump this after less than 10 Minutes?! The Gallery isn't as popular as Off Topic (Yet), be patient.

These signatures could be so much better with more effects, by adding pentooling/c4ds/lighting effects.

They all look very much alike, seems like you used exactly the same technique - which isn't a great one (boring backgrounds, bad blending, text placement/font doesn't work) - for all of them. Try something new, and take a look at a few tutorials at for example deviantART to get an idea of some of the basics. Also, I wouldn't really recommend putting on text unless you really have a decent idea of what works and what doesn't and some more experience. Taking a look a some signatures with good text that were made by others might help with this (don't rip/copy ideas exactly though).