TWR Multiclanning rule, discussion + poll.

[sparze]

We went personal, I see

 

 

 

When you war some clan, you look at combat average and amount of members. If they suit you, you declare/accept. If they have multi-clanners, it's their loss, maybe they have war or something

 

 

 

Our multi-clanners are in PvP clans and they are daily active in TK, they are part of TK (though I had no idea about 3 of them)

 

Holding eye on multi-clanners amount is in every clan's intrest, if you don't want become a team, so we are holding eye on multi-clanners and we try hold it below 10

 

 

 

TK isn't only one in Tip.it who has multi-clanners. Look at Legendz, Dragon Hunters, and teams like Legends Never Die, The Sparta and TKO Blitz.

 

Multi-clanner rule would make resign all teams/country clans and make Tip.it very small

 

 

 

Best solution is too put that multi-clanning is valid reason to decline and end this discussion but even Downfall has 3 multi-clanners.

 

 

 

I Waffle This Good post Mikk

[Dfdarkpyro]

like i said i think it would be best if we allowed people to be in 1 TWR clan, and 1 other official clan (based on runehead), and those clans cannot be on the same warring list (ie, RAW, TWR)

[Viking_Ship]

I thought evertons proof and the words of viking ship would be enough.

 

Tk has ALOT of multiclanners.Not sure if is below or above 10. If this is acceptable or not is up to the TWR mods.

 

 

 

Illusion could clear their multi-clanners too, even 1 TWR multi-clanner + 4 other multi-clanners(including Exodus)

 

Eh what do you know, you just Initiate in Illusion

 

 

 

All clans in Tip.it has some amount of multi-clanners, some less, some more.

 

At the moment it looks like TK is only clan who has multi-clanners. It's not.

 

If we gonna do something about it, all clans must be involved.

 

 

 

It's just not possible because teams and country clans are warring in same Tip.it league

 

 

 

Best solution:

 

 

 

No multi-clanning in TWR and clans can set multi-clanners rules in declaration topics

[generaldesor]

I want proof about illusions "multiclanners"

[Dfdarkpyro]

tbh i changed my mind. you should only be allowed on 1 'Official Clan RuneHead' to be allowed to war in the TWR. the clans your in can still war, but the single person is not allowed to war until he/she sorts out there multiclanning issues and dilemnas.

 

 

 

Loyalty.

 

 

 

1 Account-1 Clan.

 

 

 

i personally find most teams are a group of people who dislike a certain clan/other team and try to defeat them any way they can. Independant Alliance was a great example of this.

 

 

 

country clans shouldnt be excepted in the TWR rule, like i said before, people only need to be in one clan.

 

 

 

really, whats the gain in being in more then 1 clan? its a big hassle, and chances are you wont be in both for long. overall, i think people should pick one clan that they enjoy and have fun with, instead of multiple clans for different needs.

[generaldesor]

Still waiting for ur proof Viking Ship.

 

 

 

And Dark I dont think teams are for that, teams are just teams because its a group of people thats into warring but are from diferent clans so they call themselves a team so that their not an oficial clan and is not considered multiclanning.

 

 

 

I dont think I-A was a team lol, it was .. idk.. an alliance.

[sparze]

WTF did some votes get changed around? I was sure there was more votes for 1 yesterday.

[Dfdarkpyro]

loads more ppl posted for #2 lately.

 

 

 

 

 

<3 thats my choice

[Clay_More12]

Option 2 isn't really fair tbh, because another clan might add a member just beofre the war...

[Dfdarkpyro]

its whatever the poll goes with. and thats for the clans to sort out, if that happens im sure it will be fine.

 

 

 

i am interested to see what other options people can come up with, that aren't on the poll, i have already seen some good ones.

[Clay_More12]

its whatever the poll goes with. and thats for the clans to sort out, if that happens im sure it will be fine.

 

 

 

i am interested to see what other options people can come up with, that aren't on the poll, i have already seen some good ones.

 

How would the other clan know if you're telling the truth though?

[Dfdarkpyro]

its whatever the poll goes with. and thats for the clans to sort out, if that happens im sure it will be fine.

 

 

 

i am interested to see what other options people can come up with, that aren't on the poll, i have already seen some good ones.

 

How would the other clan know if you're telling the truth though?

 

its not hard to tell baby

 

also there really arent any tip it clans that would lie just to get ppl on their ML, its above us :thumbsup:

[DavidC]

I dont agree with multi clanning, but there should be a special rule for clans like ours. We Are a JR. Clan Called Blacknight Cadets which is a JR. Program that shows new members basic skills. Should we be penalized for doing this and having BK and BKC on the TWR?

[durai]

well i can assure this topic is cause of us but anyways should only be in 1 twr clan and rest is outside cause how i see it twr ain't built in with raw or anything so, but as i can see before its over with most clans gonna have over 50% of ml's kicked

[Sutty]

Does the Multi-Clanning Rule apply to Official Skilling Clans? E.G. Skillers United, Divination, Untouchables... etc. :ohnoes:

 

 

 

I'll be very disappointed if it does :x

[MrGwas]

well i can assure this topic is cause of us but anyways should only be in 1 twr clan and rest is outside cause how i see it twr ain't built in with raw or anything so, but as i can see before its over with most clans gonna have over 50% of ml's kicked

 

But it's still the clan community. It's not like TWR is isolated from every other clan ranking system out there, CR for example participate in wars outside of TWR as do every clan on TWR, so what use is it saying that you should only have 1 TWR clan? Multi-clanning is against the principle of clanning lol. You join a clan to fight for them and to do your best for them. What good is that when you have divided loyalty? The TWR multi-clanning rule doesn't help with that :s.

[Dfdarkpyro]

I dont agree with multi clanning, but there should be a special rule for clans like ours. We Are a JR. Clan Called Blacknight Cadets which is a JR. Program that shows new members basic skills. Should we be penalized for doing this and having BK and BKC on the TWR?

 

well if your on different ML it's completely fine, like im sure BKC has a different ML then BK does

[Uffan5]

well i can assure this topic is cause of us but anyways should only be in 1 twr clan and rest is outside cause how i see it twr ain't built in with raw or anything so, but as i can see before its over with most clans gonna have over 50% of ml's kicked

 

I don't think any clans will have to kick 50% of their members, and kicking isn't the proper term. You give them a choice of what clan they want to be in, but they can't stay in both.

[Tizi]

well i can assure this topic is cause of us but anyways should only be in 1 twr clan and rest is outside cause how i see it twr ain't built in with raw or anything so, but as i can see before its over with most clans gonna have over 50% of ml's kicked

 

 

 

 

 

i dont think any clans ml is 50% multi clanner lol...i dunno if u talking bout your own clan...

 

 

 

 

 

For example on downfall ml there is 0% multiclan

[obfuscator]

It seems that the majority favour no multi-clanning at all, but that begs the question: "What is multi-clanning?".

 

 

 

Will DH have to leave the twr? As a country clan it is expected that their members will be in another clan. And what about teams? A clear definition of multi-clanning needs to be set out if this idea were to work.

[Clay_More12]

Country/PC/SW/Skilling Clan Etc, is a not "Multi-clanning" because The "Official" Clan you're in probably doesn't have PC or SW events or is a "Country" CLan, however Skilling Clan, yes, Clans sometimes do skilling Events, but its rare and Skilling Clan main priority is to get a High Total and skill with your mates.

[obfuscator]

Country/PC/SW/Skilling Clan Etc, is a not "Multi-clanning" because The "Official" Clan you're in probably doesn't have PC or SW events or is a "Country" CLan, however Skilling Clan, yes, Clans sometimes do skilling Events, but its rare and Skilling Clan main priority is to get a High Total and skill with your mates.

 

But in terms of the TWR - DH is a warring clan on the TWR list, and Corruption is a warring clan as well. What if they were to join the TWR?

[Clay_More12]

Its highly doubtful but if thats the case, Tip It Mods can decide that out :mrgreen:

[Sutty]

well i can assure this topic is cause of us but anyways should only be in 1 twr clan and rest is outside cause how i see it twr ain't built in with raw or anything so, but as i can see before its over with most clans gonna have over 50% of ml's kicked

 

 

 

 

 

i dont think any clans ml is 50% multi clanner lol...i dunno if u talking bout your own clan...

 

 

 

 

 

For example on downfall ml there is 0% multiclan

 

 

 

Are you sure about that?

 

 

 

http://i26.tinypic.com/2nrhqtv.jpg

 

 

 

the bottom 4 of these people are multi-clanners if im not mistaken.

[Uffan5]

Thank you for doing my dirty work but i havn't heard of any of those clans, except KoA which is a community clan and HP who is on summer break.