How is the Slayer XP/h at Mutated Jadinkos? I know it should be slow because it's singlecombat, and I don't think you can cannon there. Do the drops make up for it?

 

Also, are Sagaies inferior to melee? It can hit 500+ but is much slower than a Rapier...

I haven't seen any data on exp rates, however, when I killed them for the Whip Vine, the kills were pretty quick and the charm rate seemed decent. If you take into account that the whip vine is still in the 2-4m range and apparently not uncommon,plus the noted herb drops, it may be worth doing. If you do choose to do the task, can you update me on what sort of Charm/slayer exp rates you get?

I haven't seen any data on exp rates, however, when I killed them for the Whip Vine, the kills were pretty quick and the charm rate seemed decent. If you take into account that the whip vine is still in the 2-4m range and apparently not uncommon,plus the noted herb drops, it may be worth doing. If you do choose to do the task, can you update me on what sort of Charm/slayer exp rates you get?

The charm drops are horrible... 40 kills of the Guards and only 2 blue 2 crim (didn't pick up gold/green)

I tried using Sagaies with 99 range/ext/rigour, got around 20k Slay xp/h

I'll be trying again with melee tomorrow.

Sagaies hit about as high as rapier, require time to make, and require you to keep your distance maxed at all times. Furthermore they are 1 speed slower than a rapier on rapid. That all makes them not worth it.

 

Secondly, they seem to be about on par with abyssals as their desirability goes: worth doing if you need cash badly.

Is there a way to kill the 91 slayer required ones (males) with meele, but without soul split?

 

Range seems pretty slow with sagaie*

You can range without sagaie, or melee in Karil's with protect melee and a unicorn, or try melee tanking on a unicorn.

Sagaies hit about as high as rapier, require time to make, and require you to keep your distance maxed at all times. Furthermore they are 1 speed slower than a rapier on rapid. That all makes them not worth it.

 

Secondly, they seem to be about on par with abyssals as their desirability goes: worth doing if you need cash badly.

 

A rapier on rapid?

Grammatically, that would be one of the correct ways to refer to a sagaie on rapid being slower than the rapier.

I had a task of 198. I received just under 61k experience for the task and the task took 1 hour 40 minutes (~37k slayer experience per hour).

 

Additionally, I received 26 blue charms in those 198 kills and slightly less crimson charms. I also received a whip vine drop (sold for just over 5m).

 

The primary reason that I enjoyed the task, however, was that after I was done, I collected seeds and teleport bags from the offering stone and received 3 samaden and 3 ugune seeds, so in my opinion they're worth it.

 

Slayer Experience: Above Average

Profit: Excellent

Charms: Mediocre

Speed: Average

I found a video by Number1 Boss (All credits to him for it) hopefully it gives you a little information.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFpnTgHAGC0

I had a task of 198. I received just under 61k experience for the task and the task took 1 hour 40 minutes (~37k slayer experience per hour).

 

Additionally, I received 26 blue charms in those 198 kills and slightly less crimson charms. I also received a whip vine drop (sold for just over 5m).

 

The primary reason that I enjoyed the task, however, was that after I was done, I collected seeds and teleport bags from the offering stone and received 3 samaden and 3 ugune seeds, so in my opinion they're worth it.

 

Slayer Experience: Above Average

Profit: Excellent

Charms: Mediocre

Speed: Average

Slayer experience: mediocre/below average

Profit: decent, can get lucky

Charms: mediocre/bad

Effigies: mediocre

I had a task of 198. I received just under 61k experience for the task and the task took 1 hour 40 minutes (~37k slayer experience per hour).

 

Additionally, I received 26 blue charms in those 198 kills and slightly less crimson charms. I also received a whip vine drop (sold for just over 5m).

 

The primary reason that I enjoyed the task, however, was that after I was done, I collected seeds and teleport bags from the offering stone and received 3 samaden and 3 ugune seeds, so in my opinion they're worth it.

 

Slayer Experience: Above Average

Profit: Excellent

Charms: Mediocre

Speed: Average

Slayer experience: mediocre/below average

Profit: decent, can get lucky

Charms: mediocre/bad

Effigies: mediocre

 

I factored Ugune seeds into my profit calculations. If you don't use juju farming pots/have an abundance of seeds (I got 99 hunter before Herblore Habitat was introduced, so I'm constantly low on Ugune.)