I don't think anything will change with extremes then, for the past few years it has always been about lucky specs or lucky combos. That's the only way to win a fight in rs anyway? All you can do is wait for a few lucky hits from either your main weapon or your spec weapon. There is no skill in edge pking, and very little in hybridding. Extremes should be allowed. Max hit for someone edge pking with extremes: 548 Max hit for someone edge pking without extremes: 520 (rapier/rune legs and plate/dragon defender/dragon boots/strenght ammy/neitiznot) That's not even 30 lifepoints higher. Also, the best food available in runescape are juju gumbos and baron sharks. I know they're slow to get and considered to be not worth it, but isn't that why so many pkers don't have extremes to start with? If you work for something you should get the advantage.