well if there is a seperate highscore, they would not be outshadowed but merely competin with other p2pers. I don't think you understand, some one might be number one in overall but everyone will say oh so and so is number 1 f2p is better and there would be arguments, basically p2p pay, so they deserve highscore benefits. It would be a bad move on jagex's part anyway, most hardcore players go p2p, meaning the most competition would be in p2p. If f2pers see that they can probably get to the top 20 easier on f2p, they won't become members = less money for jagex. basically, this idea has been suggested many times before and will never happen.