i guess they find it very afective against melees which are btw with armour (climb boots, zerkers, zerker rings, rune def, barrows gloves) by far overpowered compared to range and mage because of the high hits and extremly high accuracy. in staking no armour they cant use all that so tanking against them is even more affective. btw im tank too lol but that's because i always liked range since i started.. and later on i realised that its good to have high def with range/mage so i kept my melee on 78 att 79 str and trained def to 89... im 99 range 89 def 94 mage 104 cb atm if you're interested in that