It is pretty obvious the2 clan chat will be ingame, theyre not going to use some program from outside the game window to interact in it, they never did. And its not meant to replace w/e you're using, its meant to be a new convinent way to chat ingame, not everyone has Mirc, or the screen resolution to see both Mirc and the game window at the same time. Being able to have real discussions in Runescape without everybody needing to meet at the same place will be one of the greatest updates ever, no matter how basic it could be. even if it was just a multi-friend chat it would serve its purpose, but they promised us something way more useful with integrated clan structures and all. All of the bad things you're saying about it are ridiculous, since nobody knows what it will look like. Just wait and see =) Dont say its [cabbage] without first trying it. Im certain that even if it was exactly as bad as everybody said we still could find plenty of uses for it =)