Which one would be better?

 

+6 stab to compliment my fighter hat and ardy cape or +8 str?

zerker (i).

zerker (i).

Nope.

 

More efficient to use Onyx (i) for corp.

zerker (i).

Nope.

 

More efficient to use Onyx (i) for corp.

I don't know about defensive uses of +6 mage def or the accuracy on bgs, but berserker (i) comes with higher damage output for the spear.

I don't know about defensive uses of +6 mage def or the accuracy on bgs, but berserker (i) comes with higher damage output for the spear.

 

Source?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AldEhLOK6ejJdDh6Zm0xTDVQSWE3eHdZdEd6anY1aFE#gid=0

 

Operates under the assumption that accuracy is based on a die roll system like max hit. +8 strength > +6 stab attack.

Higher total offensive bonus in the form of str bonus at well above 50% hitrate. Zerker (i) is unequivocally better for DPS.

 

Onyx does next to nothing in a 6-man if you're all BGSing.

I don't know about defensive uses of +6 mage def or the accuracy on bgs, but berserker (i) comes with higher damage output for the spear.

 

hmm well when using bgs the str afforded by the zerker (i) is effectively 4 (maybe?). So it would seem onyx(i) would be better for specs, which do have some value, and so give the onyx(i) some added value. On the other hand bgs specs might devalue accuracy bonus, making the onyx(i) worse.

 

 

probably what would be *best* would be to use a warrior(i) with bgs and zerker(i) otherwise, if you're okay with switching rings. :P .

happyseeker, if that's true, than fire cape is probably better than ardy, and neit (possibly) better than fighter hat on a dps basis.

They are with enough def reduction. SWH + BGS duo teams come to mind.

Yeah... Strength > Accuracy on pretty much anything in runescape. Maybe if you're not BGS or SWH'ing at all the onyx may win, but that would be silly, why are you being silly? Stop being silly.

 

Enfield makes a good point though, for the bgs spec you want it to hit more than you need a highest hit possible, especially since it's max defense at this point, so perhaps the ring swap would be worth it, especially with a warrior.

If Strength > Accuracy why is Fighter Hat and Ardy Cape preferred over Neitiznot and Fire Cape?

Fighter has +5 total offense vs Neit's +3. Ardy has +6 total offense vs fire's +5.

 

If hitting below 50% accuracy after accounting for everything relevant, str and atk contribute the same to DPS, rendering differentiation pointless.

 

People who wear those things at corp are doing it wrong though.

So what you're saying is...

 

Fire Cape > Ardy Cape

Neitiznot > Fighter

Zerker > Onyx

Only for accuracy rates above 50%, except for the Zerker (i).

you need top consider the sum total of offensive bonuses (that you can use at once) from the items.

 

Ardy = 6 stab

fire = 4 str 1 stab

6 > 5 so ardy > fire

 

by the same logic zerker(i) beats onyx(i) by 8 str > 6 stab (and also the fact that str is generally better than accuracy bonuses anyway)

 

(This is for <50% accuracy, above which str is basically always better to have)

If Strength > Accuracy why is Fighter Hat and Ardy Cape preferred over Neitiznot and Fire Cape?

8 strength > 6 accuracy != 1 strength > 400 accuracy.

 

I'd say 1 strength is worth around 1.2 accuracy on corp. So zerker is an easy win, but fire cape is pretty close (Most people only wear the ardy because it also has a much better prayer bonus, or because other people do and they're ignorant of the actual statistics) and 5 accuracy easily beats 3 strength using my above estimation.

 

I once had an argument with someone that insisted ardy cape was better than firecape at black demons with a rapier. So after far too long telling him they're low defense i asked if he'd use ardy over firecape on experiments. He said yes. That guy was dumb.

Use stab bonus setup. You get hit less.

 

trolololol

Enfield makes a good point though, for the bgs spec you want it to hit more than you need a highest hit possible, especially since it's max defense at this point, so perhaps the ring swap would be worth it, especially with a warrior.

 

strength bonus is normally just as valuable as accuracy bonus for bgs specs actually, since how much def you reduce is proportional to what you hit. But corp halves the damage of non-spears, which is the reason why the warrior(i) is better than the zerker (i) for the specs :).