Ok, let's just take everyone's skills (except combat, like you said) And make them choose 5 of the following: Prayer, Cooking ,Woodcutting, Fletching, Fishing, Firemaking, Crafting, Smithing, Mining, Herblore, Agility, Thieving, Slayer, Farming, Runecrafting. If I had to choose 5 skills to keep (and drop the others) I'd quit. Don't care how many more skills Jagex came out with, I would quit. The only players that would be left in runescape would be those with pures. The skill restrictions are one of the major factors of why I chose runescape over others MMO's. If the position had been changed (Runescape being 15 dollars and others being 5) I would easily pay more for runescape.