Which melee skill to 99?

[Vulxai]

I've always wanted a 99 skill and I want it to be a melee skill. Which should one should I get?

 

 

 

1) Attack? Why? Use a whip?

 

 

 

2) Strength? Why? Use a d scimmy?

 

 

 

3) Defence? Why? Use a whip?

 

 

 

Thanks for replying.

 

 

 

TALLYS:

 

Attack: 5

 

Strength: 6

 

Defence: 5

 

 

 

I'd like at least 5 people in 1 category, so I have plenty of opinions.

 

 

 

Strength is winning

[RSBDavid]

1) Attack? Why? Use a whip?

 

 

 

Why? IMO it will help you train faster by hitting less 0's

 

i reccomend str next for fast training then def or leave str alone and get 99 atk and def and stake:

 

 

 

for trainin ill add a samll part of my guide located in graveyard h and a and pmg....

 

 

 

 

 

 

from 60 to 70 atk/str(737,627 xp)

 

4639 flesh crawlers

 

8284 barbarians

 

5272 minotaurs/guards

 

3314 hill giants

 

1933 moss giants

 

 

 

 

 

from 70 to 80 atk/str (1,986,068 xp)

 

7432 black knights

 

6243 rock crabs

 

12495 flesh crawlers

 

2812 fire giants

[Vulxai]

moved this part up to the first part, Mods can delete this if they want.

[Roberthree]

Strength.

 

 

 

I don't really see a reason to raise attack or defense past 70. Their effects are kinda small and their real uses are for equipping stuff. Anything past 70 is dead weight and just raises your combat level.

 

Strength provides a large, noticeable, increase in damage.

[RSBDavid]

Strength.

 

 

 

I don't really see a reason to raise attack or defense past 70. Their effects are kinda small and their real uses are for equipping stuff. Anything past 70 is dead weight and just raises your combat level.

 

Strength provides a large, noticeable, increase in damage.

 

 

 

 

 

meh str is overrated. defence provides the need for less food and they are coming out with 80+ wepons and armor later so str is backed up by atk and def..

 

 

 

berzerker helm

 

barrows gloves

 

rune drf/obby shield

 

all require def without atk the max hit eith an iron skimmy is only 16 or so

 

but with 70 atk you can hit in the 40's with whips!!

[Vulxai]

Strength.

 

 

 

I don't really see a reason to raise attack or defense past 70. Their effects are kinda small and their real uses are for equipping stuff. Anything past 70 is dead weight and just raises your combat level.

 

Strength provides a large, noticeable, increase in damage.

 

 

 

 

 

meh str is overrated. defence provides the need for less food and they are coming out with 80+ wepons and armor later so str is backed up by atk and def..

 

 

 

berzerker helm

 

barrows gloves

 

rune drf/obby shield

 

all require def without atk the max hit eith an iron skimmy is only 16 or so

 

but with 70 atk you can hit in the 40's with whips!!

 

 

 

Sorry but that's a little cornfusing (yes, I said it, CORNfusing). Are you saying def or atk?

[RSBDavid]

Strength.

 

 

 

I don't really see a reason to raise attack or defense past 70. Their effects are kinda small and their real uses are for equipping stuff. Anything past 70 is dead weight and just raises your combat level.

 

Strength provides a large, noticeable, increase in damage.

 

 

 

 

 

meh str is overrated. defence provides the need for less food and they are coming out with 80+ wepons and armor later so str is backed up by atk and def..

 

 

 

berzerker helm

 

barrows gloves

 

rune drf/obby shield

 

all require def without atk the max hit eith an iron skimmy is only 16 or so

 

but with 70 atk you can hit in the 40's with whips!!

 

 

 

Sorry but that's a little cornfusing (yes, I said it, CORNfusing). Are you saying def or atk?

 

 

 

if you want you can put a half of a vote in each but im sticking with atk

[Vulxai]

lol, another for attack then.

[Roberthree]

Everyone who has 99 attack whines about how little it does.

 

 

 

Meanwhile the guy with 99 strength is hitting 50's on other players and taking their stuff.

[Vulxai]

The good people of the clan Elite Intervention had a split vote of atk 1, str 4, and def 1, so I'll put 1 point towards str from them.

[Roberthree]

The good people of the clan Elite Intervention had a split vote of atk 1, str 4, and def 1, so I'll put 1 point towards str from them.

 

 

 

So str wins?

 

 

 

its got 5 now.

[Vulxai]

Nah, I only put one point from them.

[Vulxai]

Celebelian voted for attack.

[Vulxai]

I'd still like some more opinions.

[Hidhaeg]

Strength.. Bigger hits, etc.

 

 

 

Then get attack to around 70.

[Vulxai]

Strength.. Bigger hits, etc.

 

 

 

Then get attack to around 70.

 

 

 

My attack is already 70, and im gettin all the melee stats to 75 for sure, so I'll start the 99 from 75.

[mpg321]

Defence :thumbsup:

[Japlin Chev]

Defence, no armour for abyss, not that common, get hit less=less food \

[Howdydee2003]

forget getting 99 melee skill, be like all the other noobs and get 99 cooking or fletching ... good idea yah

[ctu]

I would go with Attack

[Vulxai]

forget getting 99 melee skill, be like all the other noobs and get 99 cooking or fletching ... good idea yah

 

 

 

Those are waaaay to easy to get. At least with melee I can go all rambo on things.

[superway25]

Id say str, def would be my 2nd choice though. You might like def more since training with whip is faster.

[crow]

Strength:

 

If you don't train on monsters with very high levels, you easily should be able to hit most of the time.

 

And once you got that 99 strength, training will be faster due the higher max hit.

 

After that get attack up, so training on higher levels of monsters goes fast too.

[Cryptogram]

Strength makes much more difference when 70+ than attack does. I'd go for high strength and defence.

 

 

 

If I had to give one of these a point - strength

[Maxx91]

Strength, obviously..

 

My strength has always been my highest

 

combat skill :)