Bump :P

I think it seems like a pretty neat idea, but it's just way to complicated for RuneScape, especially the way trading works here. Maybe if we can set up stalls or little stores in RuneScape, it would work, but for right now I just think it's too complicated to be workable.

i support :thumbsup:

i support =D> =D> =D> =D> =D>

Hmm sounds good to me... i support

Sweet - Updated support list 8-)

I support, good idea.

 

 

 

However, there should not be too much of a range between "Worst" and "Best", say about 10 - 20 stat difference for the maximum range.

1.Too complex for the majority of people, detering new players.

 

2.Inviting scams becaus it's too time consuming.

 

3.I don't like the bank solution.

 

4.It would take up BAGS of space. around 10 bytes per item.

 

with 100 you would take up around a KB.

I support, good idea.

 

 

 

However, there should not be too much of a range between "Worst" and "Best", say about 10 - 20 stat difference for the maximum range.

Course, iron would be worse than steel, rune will be better than addy etc. :wink:

 

 

 

Updated support list :)

sorry have to say no i don't really like the idea, i dont want 5 differnent whips, dragon scimmys, or dds in my bank just so i could have a different one for each training dont support

sorry have to say no i don't really like the idea, i dont want 5 differnent whips, dragon scimmys, or dds in my bank just so i could have a different one for each training dont support

Well, you'd most likely sell them #-o ...but whatever works, not everyone has to support :

Erm... It would be to confusing for me and newbies. :?

 

 

 

Do not support :shame:

What about PKing? Did you consider that?

 

If you see a kid with 99 strength and an r2h, you can expect their max hit to be a 32, but what if they have this "special" r2h? Then you won't be eating until you're at 32- hp, and he'll be able to hit you for a 35+, and if they have a "bad" r2h, then you will never know what to expect..

What about PKing? Did you consider that?

 

If you see a kid with 99 strength and an r2h, you can expect their max hit to be a 32, but what if they have this "special" r2h? Then you won't be eating until you're at 32- hp, and he'll be able to hit you for a 35+, and if they have a "bad" r2h, then you will never know what to expect..

Yes I did, and the people with more money would be better off, sure.

 

 

 

But that's kinda how life is tbh :roll: ...

 

 

 

Anyway, more of a bump. I've been away and am back :)

Its a good idea because you're bored with the same old whip every time, but its just too complicated to be realistic.

 

 

 

Add me, but just know that I only support doing this to a few weapons.

Don't support.

 

 

 

It DOES bring new items in the game... [low quality], [high quality], ....

 

+

 

There are already better and worse items in game. They are called..... mithril,addy,rune,....

Don't agree :(

 

 

 

It just make trading coward while bringing little benefit

 

 

 

for example, if i want to buy an abyssal whip, I have to say

 

"By abyssal whip 1.8k str>=82"

 

 

 

That makes those who don't use autotype in trouble

 

 

 

Also, our ecomony is simple 'cause the goods provided are homegeneous (i.e. same from the view of customers)

 

This attack, I'm afraid to say, makes the ecomomy complicated

 

 

 

should we make the hp healed by sharks a variable between 16~24, and bad shark yields a poison effect and reduce the hp of eater by 5? If we implant this update, many other updates like this have to be added. This simply ruins the economy :(

 

 

 

So, my idea is, stay away from this

I would like that... however i would be ok without it.... ill support it

 

-Support-

Alright added piman1053 and Albel_8492ed

 

 

 

...no_way2go obviously didn't get it, ah well...

 

 

 

blosssom2581 got it and disagreed. Thanks for reading :)

Bump :P

*Kicks back to first page :

its a great idea but there could be variations for example,

 

 

 

1.there would still be normal stats on the screen but there could be like a hidden effect or something.

 

 

 

con: if yu were buyign a rune scimmy it'd be on chance you get a good scimmy.

 

 

 

and with your idea all the "just got 70 att people" could just buy a bad whip for cheap and still be happy as it has the same speed and similiar stats.

 

but maybe keep it to rune stuff and higher as there isn't a point to having an "excellent" iron scimmy.

 

 

 

this idea could be developed further.

 

 

 

but i still support :thumbsup:.

That would destroy the whole point of ahaving ja prestigeous item wouldn't it?

 

Not at all. In fact, what this would do is make the better items of the same class even more prestigious than the lower ones. Someone with a whip would still look like... erm... a person with a whip. The appearance of the item wouldn't change... And generally, the effectiveness of an item wouldn't change. It would just add a new twist to items in making them different as opposed to all the same.

 

Really bad idea, people would be out to find the strongest rune scimmy for f2p pking and etc.

 

Erm... Yea... that would be the point. But that's not to say that the *best* rune scimmy would be common. As of now everyone has a rune scimmy, all the same. If they were different, a person just training for the sake of training could buy one with lower stats, while a pker could buy one with higher stats. Of course the economy would change, but it does with every update...

 

not a great idea there is already enough items that we all want no need to add more

 

No items would be added at all. The same items would be in RuneScape. The only thing that would change is the potential of those items. Some would be better, some would be worse. If you were buying a whip (for instance) you could either buy a perfect, or greater one, for more money, or a lesser one for less money. either way it would remain a whip though. It would also add to the anticipation when you get a whip-drop ;)

 

 

 

So, for the second paragraph...This is all about PKing? Well, you're pretty cheap. Look, I, personaly don't think RS should become WoW, because WoW sucks. I'm sure many agree. RS is great, it is fine the way it is now. Maybe more graphics updates but none of this.

i really find that its a bad idea

 

 

 

not only is it gonna put lots of confusion on the rs economy, its still gonna lead to more scams

 

 

 

P.S. : to anyone who reads this, this section is for things to make runescape better, not rip something from other games and say it would be good for runescape. keep that to yourselves next time u play an unoriginal game like WoW

i really find that its a bad idea

 

 

 

not only is it gonna put lots of confusion on the rs economy, its still gonna lead to more scams

 

 

 

P.S. : to anyone who reads this, this section is for things to make runescape better, not rip something from other games and say it would be good for runescape. keep that to yourselves next time u play an unoriginal game like WoW

Heh, funny how RuneScape was based off of other games. If you don't seek improvement - some in which competitors may have developed themselves - you stay behind the rest.