Hi im sorta new here and i need ppl to give me some constructive critism about my first photoshop signiture so i can make it better :). (Oh yea i can animate signitures too but the file size goes nuts so il show you one of my animated ones when i used to be addicted to mario kart ds... Check it out!

Heh, I like it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And i really like how the wording nudges when the explosion happens, Pretty cool, Nice job.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Saves the day.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But wait, Which siggy do you want us to rate..?

i need sum help with the one in my sig, wana improve it but duno how... (btw the brown dude i drew with the mouse so it might be a bit pshhh like lol)

I like how almost everything in the sig is hand made by you. It gives it a bit more originality. Anyway, the dude you drew is pretty good considering you drew it with your mouse. The background and text is a little boring but since you're still new, that's not a huge problem. Good job.

Don't post your first ever sig. To be quite honest with you, they are hardly ever decent. Remember, if you think it doesn't look good, it doesn't. For those of you who truely feel that you are hot stuff, ask for a second opinion such as family member, friend, or messenger buddy if you want a real opinion as to if it's any good. If they give good feedback, post away.

Well, apart for it being a bit too dark (I think it would look better with a background, even if it is dark, instead of plain black) his sig looks well, I can't see why he shouldn't post it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The guy on the sig looks great... consider adding the sig a little border too.

 

Don't post your first ever sig. To be quite honest with you, they are hardly ever decent. Remember, if you think it doesn't look good, it doesn't. For those of you who truely feel that you are hot stuff, ask for a second opinion such as family member, friend, or messenger buddy if you want a real opinion as to if it's any good. If they give good feedback, post away.

 

 

 

ye but the sig is good so y does it matter and it says "most the time they aren't good"

 

Don't post your first ever sig. To be quite honest with you, they are hardly ever decent. Remember, if you think it doesn't look good, it doesn't. For those of you who truely feel that you are hot stuff, ask for a second opinion such as family member, friend, or messenger buddy if you want a real opinion as to if it's any good. If they give good feedback, post away.

 

 

 

I see nothing wrong with him posting considering that it is pretty good. It's not a terrible first sig so I think he has every right to post.

 

Don't post your first ever sig. To be quite honest with you, they are hardly ever decent. Remember, if you think it doesn't look good, it doesn't. For those of you who truely feel that you are hot stuff, ask for a second opinion such as family member, friend, or messenger buddy if you want a real opinion as to if it's any good. If they give good feedback, post away.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Shutup.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It's good, great to see sigs around here with originality, infact I really like your cartoony style. The background of your sig could do with some work though, try looking at some sig tuts, there are a few in the stickys in this forum I believe. One more thing: On the animated one, the text is pretty hard to read because of the checkered background, I would suggest using a plain black or white background with perhaps a large checkered border. Also I would make the ball simply roll on, rather than fade in and then roll on.

 

Don't post your first ever sig. To be quite honest with you, they are hardly ever decent. Remember, if you think it doesn't look good, it doesn't. For those of you who truely feel that you are hot stuff, ask for a second opinion such as family member, friend, or messenger buddy if you want a real opinion as to if it's any good. If they give good feedback, post away.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This is just a rule about posting really crappy once witch his is not so don't post the rules i think everyone here has already read them.

thats the old one. i sorta tried to touch it out and make it look better if it does people? What you think??

 

 

 

 

 

 

p.s I posted my first so I can get reviews and make a better one, not just blaintly being a noob and saying something like "LOL this is my first sig ROFL, Its TEH BEST!!! LMAO!!!1", just wanted constructive critism =;

looks like you used a clouds filter thing, use some brushing like i told you to do but you ignored. maybe gradient too, experiment a little.

looks like you used a clouds filter thing, use some brushing like i told you to do but you ignored. maybe gradient too, experiment a little.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

actually in my latest one (the one im using in my sig) is the up date on the old one (the one with the big empty space), i had a cloud filter thing in that but i also used the brush tool to create a fire like effect. Any CC's on the new updated one in the sigi please? :?:

(BTW I based it on my character in Runescape, which explains the black armour, Mith Sword, red cape and red amulet, i just think the black armour looks cool :)

I think it improved a lot with that background. Maybe the yinyang seems a bit lost... Try adding a little 2px or 3px border, it makes sigs look more finished.

I think it improved a lot with that background. Maybe the yinyang seems a bit lost... Try adding a little 2px or 3px border, it makes sigs look more finished.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thanks for the tips Aijiru!

 

 

 

Old one...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Updated one (with border and some more brushiness)...

 

 

 

 

 

 

Any better?

I like it more than the older one. Althrough I'm not an expert, good job :D

yayyy \ woo

Hey maybe you should make a whole cartoon signature, this time without an oversized person :shame:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I like the bored on it so far, wonder who helped you..