You think this entire topic makes you want to scream? Shoot, one quick glance at your post nearly had my blood boiling. Figuratively, of course -- no sense in getting worked up on someone else's difference in opinion. Now, if you had cared to read through the entire post (it's long, but you'd have saved yourself a lot of embarrassment), then you'd have realized that the more constructive points on this topic hinged on what Members don't normally use, or what they could realistically part with. Be reasonable now -- what person do you know is willing to pay $6 to use claws, Halberds, Splitbark armor, or Frogskin armor? Most, if not everyone that's posted here believe that freeplayers shouldn't get something that Members use a whole lot, but there's nothing wrong with giving them stuff we don't ever seem to use. You also seem to be very, very wrong about not helping it grow. Where the hell do you think Members come from, thin air? Lastly, on the subject of deserving stuff - we already freaking KNOW that F2P doesn't deserve anything. They still get updates though - on that tone, you could argue that they don't "deserve" it. I think that your "Logic to English" translator is broken. Go back, reread the post, and come back with some well thought-out response to it. You know, I couldn't care less about the halberds. However, just becasue most members don't use them doesn't mean that F2P suddenly has the right have it themselves. And thank you very much, I am aware that P2P comes from F2P.