I say that they should. It's much harder (in some cases) to get a skillcape in F2P, so why should they be deprived of the joy of owning one? Members DO NOT pay $5 a month for skill capes, we pay for more updates, quests, skills (a new one will be released for F2P), items, monsters and more. By allowing F2P to have skillcapes, the F2P world does not need to get any larger. The NPCs just need to be moved into an F2P world.