Currently, i'm training Slayer for charms. But is there a faster, more efficient way to collecting charms than doing Slayer?

waterfiends

I've been slaying for a bit, and slayer is the way to go.

I've been slaying for a bit, and slayer is the way to go.

 

 

 

he said a faster and more efficient not something he just said in the first post

rock lobs

I've been slaying for a bit, and slayer is the way to go.

 

 

 

he said a faster and more efficient not something he just said in the first post

 

And I was merely stating he's better off with slayer.

Burst/barrage at rock lobs = expensive but very fast (140 crim an hour?)

 

 

 

Waterfiends with zam spear or dharoks is next best, about 110 ish per hour (give or take, depends how good you are)

 

 

 

They'r the two good ones. After that you're stuck with nechs (you cant kill them), dust devils (you NEARLY can), and not a lot else that is all that good.

 

 

 

That's for charm collecting. Wether to d othat or keep slaying depends how much you want slay xp, and how much you have to spend.

Rock lobs/Waterfiends are by FAR faster than Slayer.

 

 

 

But you miss out on Slayer xp.

 

 

 

....

 

 

 

It's your choice, the decision is that simple.

Once you get to 65, you can try bursting or chinning dust devils in chaos tunnels. It's faster than killing them normally, and you can pick up 60-70 charms an hour that way, more once you get good at it. Not quite the payoff of rock lobs in terms of charms, but it's a fast way to get through dust devil tasks if nothing else. And it's safer and easier to get to than rock lobsters (I'm basing that on what I've read - never done rock lobs myself :? ).

^Thats just not right; they dont box very well.

 

 

 

Cockroaches are good.

Once you get to 65, you can try bursting or chinning dust devils in chaos tunnels. It's faster than killing them normally, and you can pick up 60-70 charms an hour that way, more once you get good at it. Not quite the payoff of rock lobs in terms of charms, but it's a fast way to get through dust devil tasks if nothing else. And it's safer and easier to get to than rock lobsters (I'm basing that on what I've read - never done rock lobs myself :? ).

 

 

 

Dust Devils don't have good charm drop rates. Waterfiends are much better.

 

 

 

Of course, you're right about the rock lobbies, but if you're willing to chin dust devils, just melee them. It's faster and more effective.

^Thats just not right; they dont box very well.

 

 

 

Sure they do, it just takes a bit of work.

Once you get to 65, you can try bursting or chinning dust devils in chaos tunnels. It's faster than killing them normally, and you can pick up 60-70 charms an hour that way, more once you get good at it. Not quite the payoff of rock lobs in terms of charms, but it's a fast way to get through dust devil tasks if nothing else. And it's safer and easier to get to than rock lobsters (I'm basing that on what I've read - never done rock lobs myself :? ).

 

 

 

Dust Devils don't have good charm drop rates. Waterfiends are much better.

 

 

 

Of course, you're right about the rock lobbies, but if you're willing to chin dust devils, just melee them. It's faster and more effective.

 

 

 

I was killing dusties faster with ice burst than a level 133 guy was with melee in the chaos tunnels. But it did take some practice.

I was talking about a cost-effective method, but since you're training summoning, I guess it doesn't matter much ... but if you're willing to use ancients on DUST DEVILS, just go to Rock Lobsters already.

 

 

 

Once again, dust devil drop rates are LOW.

Not low, above average.

I'm sorry, I took it that you meant faster when you said, um, the word faster ;)

 

 

 

And Dust Devils have a pretty good charm drop rate for a fairly low level monster. I'd say you get a charm from 40-50% of kills, the majority of which are crimson, most of the rest being gold. Not too shabby.

[hide=quotes]

Not low, above average.

 

 

 

I'm sorry, I took it that you meant faster when you said, um, the word faster ;)

 

 

 

And Dust Devils have a pretty good charm drop rate for a fairly low level monster. I'd say you get a charm from 40-50% of kills, the majority of which are crimson, most of the rest being gold. Not too shabby.

[/hide]

 

For that kind of NPC, I'd agree, but for a slayer monster, the charm drop rate could be better.

Bursting doesnt work well there, end of - its just stupid and useless.

 

 

 

@Lady no not really. Crimsons are the 2nd best charm and for an actual slayer monster it's much better than anyone would expect

^ If you were talking about blue charms with Dust Devils, I wouldn't be too surprised if everyone camped there.

 

 

 

I guess i"m just asking for more, but dust devils don't seem to give enough charms for me.

Bursting doesnt work well there, end of - its just stupid and useless.

 

 

 

Arranging 5 dust devils into a 3x3 area is not difficult to do. Further testing tonight may (or may not) yield a way to arrange 6 or (doubtfully) 7. It's a very fast method for killing them, far from stupid and useless.

At dusties on most normal sized servers (1kish ppl) i sometimes have to wait for spawns as i kill them fast with melee and combat familiar. so just melee them bursting is a waste

 

 

 

 

 

you can either burst lobs kill waterfiends or slayer. in the very long run slayer is most efficient. if you want your levels soon lobs/fiends are a faster bet

Somehow I doubt that you kill 8 dust devils before the first one respawns, even at max melee - which, as you can see, I'm nowhere near. Their respawn rate can't be more than 30 seconds even on a half-full world. I usually burst them on a full or nearly full world, and it takes around 10 seconds for them to respawn. I watched a level 133 with a bunyip kill them, he wasn't killing more than 2 before the first one had respawned, and usually not even that fast.

I 5-10% str pray, iron titan. I ocassionaly find myself waiting for a spawn but its not that often, but it does happen. I use the west room if that matters. though keep in mind my titan is always fighting something so i guess thats maybe why i need to wait for a new one sometimes

I also find myself troubled with spawns, especially when there's another person there.

 

in the very long run slayer is most efficient

 

Define most efficient. To some, Slayer xp could have a net worth of 0, because fact is it doesn't give any true bonuses. (Besides maybe a Slayer drop for the first few days of a new monster)

Well I would suggest if You're at least 85 att/str to go to waterfiends, else go to dust devils, they're decent.