I dont see what the fuss is. Personally I find it would be a good thing to let them be in PVP, as they require skills outside of combat. But isnt PVP just about combat? ... EDIT: @Abby, Nothing in runescape is hard. It's all clicking. Sure, length of time and boredom make it more annoying and, well, longer, but it isnt hard. If you're playing a game for competitiveness or a challenge then you shouldnt play runescape.