Question 1 The whip has 0 stab bonus so wouldn't that be a bad decision? :huh: I currently have a Dragon Halabred which has a 70 stab bonus, does anyone think that would work, the only downside is I wouldnt be able to hold a shield, which sucks becasue the scarab still hit 18s on ocassion :-( Question 2 If i did loan an item from someone and died, what happens to that loaned item, am i punished for losing it? Question 3 I'm 1.5mil away from being able to afford full Gutham, would it make sense to buy Gutham, or not bother with the risk. Question 4. Anyone here able to loan a Zamorak spear for an hour sometime this week? 1. The whip can only be used with slash, but its bonuses and speed are so high that it's a good choice for most monsters. The halberd is best if you can use it to safespot; otherwise, it's too slow for most fights except to use for its special (hits twice on large NPCs). 2. The loaned item will go back to its owner with no other repercussions. 3. I've never used Guthan's so I can't give you an informed opinion on that. 4. I don't have one.