Phat = Skill cape Phat > Skill cape Skill cape > Phat Whats right? All of them. Its just who you ask.... Ask some one with a blue Phat, what would they say? Then ask some one with 99 slayer that is "poor", he might say Skill cape > Phat. Any one can merchent to get a Phat, but can one take the time it takes to get a 99 skill? Thats the real question.