Tipit's player-made guild!

[Skill_Caster]

you need to have a world/place that isnt loaded with other people who arnt tip.it people. Every world i see has 100 people in lumby alone. You need a place not so packed all the time with random people. You need a place that has monsters (high-level, good training). This would make people always want to stop by and hang out for 5-10mins and share there day. A place where 1 or 2 good Money making sources are around, and the bank is used frequently by the people that use that method of training. Thats why I think it should be canafis. Canafis (spell check pl0x) this city has the slayer tower which has bloodvelds (spell check), abysal demons and more to much to list. It is one of the closest cities to barrows which we all know is very very popular. Its near some what ghost ahoy You were counting hams so i thought this might count. You can also of course fletch there which i believe is more in the open then maybe fletching or crafting hides in the basement of some city or on the top of it. Canafis also has the only spot to get mort mushroom things for heblore. Also there is werewolves right next to the bank which is often a slayer monster for some people. Slayer master right down the road where you can buy supplies from. A clothe store with all sorts of colors, A food store Where u can buy rarely though raw sharks and other food. The taxadermy to stuff your monsters to put up on your wall at your house. Also your house can be set up to allow you to go directly to canafis. Canafis also has A large number of quest that go through it. The experiments are also right down the road for pures and mid lvl training (there awesome). Im sure im missing alot of stuff but i hope some of you are getting the feel for where im going with this.

 

 

 

Hmm, I dunno, I kind of like that idea too.

[Soprano]

Great idea, but as posted above, a better location.

[malo2]

Sounds like a great idea.

 

 

 

Isn't world 99 edge, already sort of an official player made guild?

um no... unless i missed something.

[Mollerz]

you need to have a world/place that isnt loaded with other people who arnt tip.it people. Every world i see has 100 people in lumby alone. You need a place not so packed all the time with random people. You need a place that has monsters (high-level, good training). This would make people always want to stop by and hang out for 5-10mins and share there day. A place where 1 or 2 good Money making sources are around, and the bank is used frequently by the people that use that method of training. Thats why I think it should be canafis. Canafis (spell check pl0x) this city has the slayer tower which has bloodvelds (spell check), abysal demons and more to much to list. It is one of the closest cities to barrows which we all know is very very popular. Its near some what ghost ahoy You were counting hams so i thought this might count. You can also of course fletch there which i believe is more in the open then maybe fletching or crafting hides in the basement of some city or on the top of it. Canafis also has the only spot to get mort mushroom things for heblore. Also there is werewolves right next to the bank which is often a slayer monster for some people. Slayer master right down the road where you can buy supplies from. A clothe store with all sorts of colors, A food store Where u can buy rarely though raw sharks and other food. The taxadermy to stuff your monsters to put up on your wall at your house. Also your house can be set up to allow you to go directly to canafis. Canafis also has A large number of quest that go through it. The experiments are also right down the road for pures and mid lvl training (there awesome). Im sure im missing alot of stuff but i hope some of you are getting the feel for where im going with this.

 

 

 

More of a combat PMG don't you think?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I am going to suggest: Falador East Bank.

 

 

 

There is a nearby range to the east.

 

Mining Guild, hundreds of coal, also, adamantite, mithril and clay nearby for such things as tablets and smithing training.

 

Furnace near if unable to access such places as Port Phasmatys or cannot get to TzHaar with ease.

 

TWO Tree patches nearby.

 

An Allotment & Herb patch to the south.

 

Water supply to the east.

 

You can get 4 people firemaking at the same time in a line.

 

Estate Agent.

 

Near a teleport.

 

Fast access to merchanting if necessary (Quick Hop to W2).

 

Easy access to cheap coal and iron supplies (Quick Hop to W1).

 

3/4 yews trees spread to the south.

 

Air altar (If you really wish :lol:).

 

 

 

 

 

I mean, the things you mentioned in the first post, an axe repairer, that's a quick teleport away and back. Willows and oaks nearby, I would rather go somewhere where there is lots of that specific tree than go with 1 or 2 crowded with lots of people. Swamp Tar, how often is that needed? Quick access to Al-Kharid, I'm sure if people wanted to have quick access they would just teleport. Rats, Edgeville sewers are MUCH better, there are only two rats in Lumbridge Dungeon. Prayer Altar, I'm sure you wouldn't be doing massive amounts of combat at Lumbridge. Access to Dorgesh-Kaan, I'm sure the point of the guild is to get players together, sending them to Dorgesh-Kaan means they aren't really part of the guild. Quick access to Dorgeshuun mines, very few rocks, if people wanted to powermine anyway, 90% of them will go to granite.

 

 

 

These are just my opinions. I mean, if I was fletching or fetching water, great, Lumbridge, thumbs up. But Falador meets many more requirements such as the mining guild, furnace and the farming patches.

 

 

 

Just my thoughts

 

~Calcium

[malo2]

you need to have a world/place that isnt loaded with other people who arnt tip.it people. Every world i see has 100 people in lumby alone. You need a place not so packed all the time with random people. You need a place that has monsters (high-level, good training). This would make people always want to stop by and hang out for 5-10mins and share there day. A place where 1 or 2 good Money making sources are around, and the bank is used frequently by the people that use that method of training. Thats why I think it should be canafis. Canafis (spell check pl0x) this city has the slayer tower which has bloodvelds (spell check), abysal demons and more to much to list. It is one of the closest cities to barrows which we all know is very very popular. Its near some what ghost ahoy You were counting hams so i thought this might count. You can also of course fletch there which i believe is more in the open then maybe fletching or crafting hides in the basement of some city or on the top of it. Canafis also has the only spot to get mort mushroom things for heblore. Also there is werewolves right next to the bank which is often a slayer monster for some people. Slayer master right down the road where you can buy supplies from. A clothe store with all sorts of colors, A food store Where u can buy rarely though raw sharks and other food. The taxadermy to stuff your monsters to put up on your wall at your house. Also your house can be set up to allow you to go directly to canafis. Canafis also has A large number of quest that go through it. The experiments are also right down the road for pures and mid lvl training (there awesome). Im sure im missing alot of stuff but i hope some of you are getting the feel for where im going with this.

since when was lumby loaded with people? im in world 99 lumby at this moment and there are about 15 people in the whole town. Also, canifis is very un useful, it lacks basic features such as a water source or range, the only thing its really good for is barrows and slayer.

 

 

 

In reply to ca2theone:

 

 

 

There is a nearby range to the east.

 

Much better in lumby

 

 

 

Mining Guild, hundreds of coal, also, adamantite, mithril and clay nearby

 

sadly very few p2pers mine at all or smith.

 

Furnace near if unable to access such places as Port Phasmatys or cannot i guess thats good, but then again. lumbys 1 click bank is excelent for super heating, which you should know is many times faster than a furnace if you are interested in the mage xp.

 

get to TzHaar with ease.um, how?

 

TWO Tree patches nearby.one is rather far but alright

 

An Allotment & Herb patch to the south.if you find that one useful than maybe

 

Water supply to the east.lumbys water supply is many times closer

 

You can get 4 people firemaking at the same time in a line.cant argue with that one

 

Estate Agent.not very useful. considering you wouldnt just randomly decide to go to one, you usually do when you are constructiong a house, and at that time you would not be near fally anyway.

 

Near a teleport.so is lumby, 2 teleports in fact, one being free of charge. Also, dont forget that lumbridge also has a teleother, which requires an astounding 8 lvls lower magic than fally teleother.

 

Fast access to merchanting if necessary (Quick Hop to W2).then you will be leaving the guild, and even if you do manage to make it to wold 2, a simple teleport makes no difference.

 

Easy access to cheap coal and iron supplies (Quick Hop to W1).see above

 

3/4 yews trees spread to the south.i suppose if you use those

 

Air altar (If you really wish Laughing). try world 66.

 

 

 

its true that fally has things lumby doesnt, but lumby still wins in most of the vital features (such as range, water source, bank, teleports, ect)

[tylersk8shop]

Not really great for firemaking. People want to be able to do straight lines, this is why I am going to suggest: Falador East Bank.

 

 

 

There is a nearby range to the east.

 

Mining Guild, hundreds of coal, also, adamantite, mithril and clay nearby for such things as tablets and smithing training.

 

Furnace near if unable to access such places as Port Phasmatys or cannot get to TzHaar with ease.

 

TWO Tree patches nearby.

 

An Allotment & Herb patch to the south.

 

Water supply to the east.

 

You can get 4 people firemaking at the same time in a line.

 

Estate Agent.

 

Near a teleport.

 

Fast access to merchanting if necessary (Quick Hop to W2).

 

Easy access to cheap coal and iron supplies (Quick Hop to W1).

 

3/4 yews trees spread to the south.

 

Air altar (If you really wish :lol:).

 

 

 

 

 

I mean, the things you mentioned in the first post, an axe repairer, that's a quick teleport away and back. Willows and oaks nearby, I would rather go somewhere where there is lots of that specific tree than go with 1 or 2 crowded with lots of people. Swamp Tar, how often is that needed? Quick access to Al-Kharid, I'm sure if people wanted to have quick access they would just teleport. Rats, Edgeville sewers are MUCH better, there are only two rats in Lumbridge Dungeon. Prayer Altar, I'm sure you wouldn't be doing massive amounts of combat at Lumbridge. Access to Dorgesh-Kaan, I'm sure the point of the guild is to get players together, sending them to Dorgesh-Kaan means they aren't really part of the guild. Quick access to Dorgeshuun mines, very few rocks, if people wanted to powermine anyway, 90% of them will go to granite.

 

 

 

These are just my opinions. I mean, if I was fletching or fetching water, great, Lumbridge, thumbs up. But Falador meets many more requirements such as the mining guild, furnace and the farming patches.

 

 

 

Just my thoughts

 

~Calcium

 

I would have to agree with this somewhat

[wurmskin]

Jeez, at this rate, we might have to have a poll to decide which specific area/city we'll have this PMG in. I hope you guys are ready for alot of suggestions :) . Good luck to you! We should have an official opening day when it comes to it. I'm sure it'll be a matter of time before we find the 'perfect' area.

[Master_Smither]

Very nice idea now if only people read this thread more.

 

 

 

I won't be there no anvils :(

 

 

 

But best of luck with the guide

[Mollerz]

Yeah, the only good place for anvils however is Varrock West Bank, but there is NOTHING else there :?

[ThoseTheBrokes]

I shouldn't think there is one place for everyones needs.

 

 

 

so why not stretch the guild into two locations?

[malo2]

Jeez, at this rate, we might have to have a poll to decide which specific area/city we'll have this PMG in. I hope you guys are ready for alot of suggestions :) . Good luck to you! We should have an official opening day when it comes to it. I'm sure it'll be a matter of time before we find the 'perfect' area.

um still awaiting suggestions for a possible better town. The fally one was ok, but lumby is far more useful.

 

 

 

I shouldn't think there is one place for everyones needs.

 

 

 

so why not stretch the guild into two locations?

we first need to make one location work before we even think about another.

[Made0f12une]

I shouldn't think there is one place for everyones needs.

 

 

 

so why not stretch the guild into two locations?

 

 

 

Our goal is to unite tip.it in one location as a whole. This might have to be done to fancy EVERYONES needs

[tylersk8shop]

um still awaiting suggestions for a possible better town. The fally one was ok, but lumby is far more useful.

 

I think fally is much more usefull then lumbridge, Unless you are fletching or filling stuff with water. Fally has much better and many more firemaking spots, Closer furnace, A general store, White knights caslte (training), A spinning wheel, 2 Banks, Mining guild, Dwarven Mines, Oak trees, Yew trees to the south, A tree patch, Herb/allotment/flower patch to the south, Cows to the south (cow hides), The crafting guild (not toooo far away), Fally has a nice park for hanging out in or alching even playing little games, Realter guy, Starting location of many quests, Its not very crowded, Its got a fountain not far from the east bank, Air Altar, Many gaurds which you can kill for clues, A house portal thats a little ways away, And I'm sure theres Many more things.

[malo2]

um still awaiting suggestions for a possible better town. The fally one was ok, but lumby is far more useful.

 

I think fally is much more usefull then lumbridge, Unless you are fletching or filling stuff with water. Fally has much better and many more firemaking spots, Closer furnace, A general store, White knights caslte (training), A spinning wheel, 2 Banks, Mining guild, Dwarven Mines, Oak trees, Yew trees to the south, A tree patch, Herb/allotment/flower patch to the south, Cows to the south (cow hides), The crafting guild (not toooo far away), Fally has a nice park for hanging out in or alching even playing little games, Realter guy, Starting location of many quests, Its not very crowded, Its got a fountain not far from the east bank, Air Altar, Many gaurds which you can kill for clues, A house portal thats a little ways away, And I'm sure theres Many more things.

maybe you should read the list i made before you make a reply?

[tylersk8shop]

yeah I read it. I'm just saying why I think fally is wayyy better then lumbridge

[doomy]

Nvm lol, good idea :P

[Wachtwoord]

Lumby isn't very good, yes it has a lot, but no one really uses it. Willows and oaks? BA and CW are much better. Cooking? Rogues Den. Fly fishing? Shilo village. A lot of things people don't need very often or hardly do. How often do you need your axe repaired? How often do you need that underground city? Why'd you go to Al Kharid by that short cut, if there are 2 easy teleports there? Etc. The only thing it's the best for is water filling.

 

 

 

I'd say Edge, which has a few things better then lumby:

 

-First; you can also train firemaking there, very important, it's trained often there already.

 

-Second; it's a good pking or anything else you want to do in the wild meeting place.

 

-Third; There are already a lot of people there! People don't like changes, the less you change the better. If you make Edge the PMG, more people will attend because it's less of a change!

[Star_Fox]

im sticking with 99 edge, this ideas too basic.

[Wachtwoord]

im sticking with 99 edge, this ideas too basic.

 

Thank you! You just proved my last point.

[gotsol]

Canafis is alot combat based pmg i would agree with that also. But it is also good for money making like i said with the morty mushrooms, You can fletch and firemak there to getting idk 10+ people in a line. I just think canafis would be a better place. Ill post my suggestion area again why its good.

 

 

 

 

 

gotsol wrote:

 

you need to have a world/place that isnt loaded with other people who arnt tip.it people. Every world i see has 100 people in lumby alone. You need a place not so packed all the time with random people. You need a place that has monsters (high-level, good training). This would make people always want to stop by and hang out for 5-10mins and share there day. A place where 1 or 2 good Money making sources are around, and the bank is used frequently by the people that use that method of training. Thats why I think it should be canafis. Canafis (spell check pl0x) this city has the slayer tower which has bloodvelds (spell check), abysal demons and more to much to list. It is one of the closest cities to barrows which we all know is very very popular. Its near some what ghost ahoy You were counting hams so i thought this might count. You can also of course fletch there which i believe is more in the open then maybe fletching or crafting hides in the basement of some city or on the top of it. Canafis also has the only spot to get mort mushroom things for heblore. Also there is werewolves right next to the bank which is often a slayer monster for some people. Slayer master right down the road where you can buy supplies from. A clothe store with all sorts of colors, A food store Where u can buy rarely though raw sharks and other food. The taxadermy to stuff your monsters to put up on your wall at your house. Also your house can be set up to allow you to go directly to canafis. Canafis also has A large number of quest that go through it. The experiments are also right down the road for pures and mid lvl training (there awesome). Im sure im missing alot of stuff but i hope some of you are getting the feel for where im going with this.

 

 

 

 

 

And back to malo2 , lumby is always packed with tons of lvl 50 and lower peope, lol.

[malo2]

yeah I read it. I'm just saying why I think fally is wayyy better then lumbridge

read it again then.

[tylersk8shop]

yeah I read it. I'm just saying why I think fally is wayyy better then lumbridge

read it again then.

 

-.-

[Elessar3019]

Here's my take on this:

 

 

 

Lumbridge

 

Good choice, but JaGeX aimed it more at the lower-lvl player. It would work, but doesn't seem to be the popular location.

 

 

 

Canifis

 

Not going to work, because there is no accesible teleport to it. Either you beat DT (no humble feat) or visit a bank before going and use the Fairy Ring. Also, the aesthetic aura of Canifis isn't such that people want to go there to "hang out".

 

 

 

East Fally

 

Probably just as good as Lumbridge, it does have 2 guilds nearby and some firelines, which are components Lumbridge is missing. My vote would most likely go here.

 

 

 

Edgeville

 

Since this is the "official" hang-out place for Tip.it already, it should definitely be on the list. I don't think it's best, since it's lacking several features that the others have, but certainly consider it.

[gotsol]

Here's my take on this:

 

 

 

Lumbridge

 

Good choice, but JaGeX aimed it more at the lower-lvl player. It would work, but doesn't seem to be the popular location.

 

 

 

Canifis

 

Not going to work, because there is no accesible teleport to it. Either you beat DT (no humble feat) or visit a bank before going and use the Fairy Ring. Also, the aesthetic aura of Canifis isn't such that people want to go there to "hang out".

 

 

 

East Fally

 

Probably just as good as Lumbridge, it does have 2 guilds nearby and some firelines, which are components Lumbridge is missing. My vote would most likely go here.

 

 

 

Edgeville

 

Since this is the "official" hang-out place for Tip.it already, it should definitely be on the list. I don't think it's best, since it's lacking several features that the others have, but certainly consider it.

 

 

 

Actually canafis is better then you think, you can make your house have a teleport directly towards canifis or you can use ecto to get right next to it. Canafis would be ment for the higher lvls experienced in barrows or 85+ slay

[malo2]

Lumby isn't very good, yes it has a lot, but no one really uses it. Willows and oaks? BA and CW are much better. Cooking? Rogues Den. Fly fishing? Shilo village. A lot of things people don't need very often or hardly do. How often do you need your axe repaired? How often do you need that underground city? Why'd you go to Al Kharid by that short cut, if there are 2 easy teleports there? Etc. The only thing it's the best for is water filling.

 

 

 

I'd say Edge, which has a few things better then lumby:

 

-First; you can also train firemaking there, very important, it's trained often there already.

 

-Second; it's a good pking or anything else you want to do in the wild meeting place.

 

-Third; There are already a lot of people there! People don't like changes, the less you change the better. If you make Edge the PMG, more people will attend because it's less of a change!

most of those examples were minor, anyway, you should have read the list more carefully because you missed some thing you mentioned yourself, such as the range in lumby, which actually has a lower burn rate than any standard range, thus its found useful by many people. Anyway, strangely you chose the most insignificant points.

 

 

 

Anway, the only thing edgeville is good for is pking and firemaking, anything else? what this means is that nobody other than the people already there have any reason to come.

 

 

 

And back to malo2 , lumby is always packed with tons of lvl 50 and lower peope, lol.

i dont think i need to show my point about canifis anymore: a very useless town. and if you say lumby is always packed, why dont you come down to w99 lumby yourself right now and point those 100 lvl 50s out yourself?