October 16, 200817 yr how much do you think they would sell for? (i dont want them as tradeable im just asking how much do you think a charm is worth....) paste this: gold: gp green: gp blue: gp crimson: gp Joined RS Dec 24th 2004.99 Hunter 14.08.09 10084th99 Cooking 17.06.11 188188th << Drum and Bass
October 16, 200817 yr Gold, probably below 1k each Green, around 1k Crimson, 1-5k Blue, 25k ;) This is just an estimate, and how I value them, however, it would kill the RS ecomony if they became tradable lol
October 16, 200817 yr Gold, probably below 1k each Green, around 1k Crimson, 1-5k Blue, 25k ;) This is just an estimate, and how I value them, however, it would kill the RS ecomony if they became tradable lol when i have an abberant spectres task i get like 10 blues per hour,so that would mean 250k worth of charms extra? :shock: alot of people would go hunt them and they would fall so hard,id value them around 4k ea.
October 16, 200817 yr at the start theyd be high but then would plummet after a while. im guessing theyd be more realisticly like this Gold, 200-300 Green, 450-600 Crimson, 500-700 blue, 1-1.5k those are my estimates
October 16, 200817 yr Not another thread... gold: 2k gp green: 7k gp blue: 40k gp crimson: 12k gp It's what I pay in time\cost for them when bursting\doing waterfiends; I'd get 99 summoning right now if they ever came out priced like that. Drops: 1x Draconic Visage, 56x Abyssal Whip, 5x Demon Head, D Drops: 37, Barrows Drops: 43, DK Drops: 29GWD drops: 14,000x Bars, 1x Armadyl Hilt, 2x Armadyl Skirt, 4x Sara Sword, 1x Saradomin Hilt, 8x Bandos Hilt, 8x Bandos Platebody, 9x Bandos Tassets, 4x Bandos Boots, 43x Godsword Shard, 82x Dragon BootsDry streak records: Saradomin 412 kills Bandos 988 kills Spirit Mages 633 kills - Slayer Sucks
October 17, 200817 yr Not another thread... gold: 2k gp green: 7k gp blue: 40k gp crimson: 12k gp It's what I pay in time\cost for them when bursting\doing waterfiends; I'd get 99 summoning right now if they ever came out priced like that. You can't balance Runescape's economy by math, honestly. [Summoning guide (AOW)] [Slayer guide] [Melee & Brawl player]
October 20, 200817 yr Isn't that like saying "what if bunny ears/scythes/yoyos/a night with Andrew" was tradeable? Tradeable charms would be the worst thing to happen to summoning and they are untradeable for a reason. I'd rather die for what I believe in than live for anything else.Name Removed by Administrator ~Turtlefemm
October 20, 200817 yr Isn't that like saying "what if bunny ears/scythes/yoyos/a night with Andrew" was tradeable? Tradeable charms would be the worst thing to happen to summoning and they are untradeable for a reason. There's nothing wrong with speculation, it's only a "what if?" :roll:
October 20, 200817 yr gold 25 gp green 100gp red 500gp blue 1-2k "It's not a rest for me, it's a rest for the weights." - Dom Mazzetti
October 22, 200817 yr r u ppl nuts?! ive see nsome ppl post gold charms being :1-2k ea?! if tht was the case the 250 charms u get for starting quest tht means u could sell for 250k - 500k sound reasonable?
October 23, 200817 yr r u ppl nuts?! ive see nsome ppl post gold charms being :1-2k ea?! if tht was the case the 250 charms u get for starting quest tht means u could sell for 250k - 500k sound reasonable? Spirit shield, anyone? (Although that quest was significantly harder) Oh, dear What If Machine, what if charms were tradeable? Gold: 500-700 gp Green: 1-2K Crimson: 2-3 Blue: 5-7K Filesharer.org - Upload your mugshot to support The Pirate Bay!
October 24, 200817 yr r u ppl nuts?! ive see nsome ppl post gold charms being :1-2k ea?! if tht was the case the 250 charms u get for starting quest tht means u could sell for 250k - 500k sound reasonable? Spirit shield, anyone? (Although that quest was significantly harder) Oh, dear What If Machine, what if charms were tradeable? Gold: 500-700 gp Green: 1-2K Crimson: 2-3 Blue: 5-7K k i saw the chart of spirit sheild and tht was...like real life stock market bad but i dont get wat point ur trying to make....u hate me or u agree w/ me? soz for being so stupid :P
October 28, 200817 yr gold 25 gp green 100gp red 500gp blue 1-2k At 2k per blue you could do 89-99 summon with the best possible pouches (=most xp and 2nds that actually can be gotten) would take around 4 hours and cost around 23-24m (includes 2nds, I assume you'd have enough shards from swapping the previouc pouches) gp. After doing the pouches you could alch them, swap for shards or sell and make the losses to around 10-15m. I don't know about you but in my eyes that's just not how it should be: 1. Bursting for the charms costs now more and that's if you do greens and crimsons too. If I wanted to burst for blues only it would take me months and costs tens of times more. 2. That would probably be the fastest possible xp on whole game on both factors: pure time used and the time to use+time to collect the money wise. If charms for some odd reason were tradeable, they would be at least 3-5 times more expensive than you stated. I base my opinion on the fact that for lesser cost it would be cheaper and faster than prayer, yet more helping at higher levels. I'd rather die for what I believe in than live for anything else.Name Removed by Administrator ~Turtlefemm
October 28, 200817 yr i wouldn't give it must respect with those prices and having it cost less than herblore doesn't really make sense to me... |ty lit 4 sig| |8919th to 99 fishing|
October 29, 200817 yr gold 25 gp green 100gp red 500gp blue 1-2k At 2k per blue you could do 89-99 summon with the best possible pouches (=most xp and 2nds that actually can be gotten) would take around 4 hours and cost around 23-24m (includes 2nds, I assume you'd have enough shards from swapping the previouc pouches) gp. After doing the pouches you could alch them, swap for shards or sell and make the losses to around 10-15m. I don't know about you but in my eyes that's just not how it should be: 1. Bursting for the charms costs now more and that's if you do greens and crimsons too. If I wanted to burst for blues only it would take me months and costs tens of times more. 2. That would probably be the fastest possible xp on whole game on both factors: pure time used and the time to use+time to collect the money wise. If charms for some odd reason were tradeable, they would be at least 3-5 times more expensive than you stated. I base my opinion on the fact that for lesser cost it would be cheaper and faster than prayer, yet more helping at higher levels. No, bursting for charms would serve no purpose, as you could just buy charms. And secondaries would shoot up. [Summoning guide (AOW)] [Slayer guide] [Melee & Brawl player]
November 1, 200817 yr Gold... probably 400 gp-2K area Green... Probably around 1-5K Crimson... Probably around 5-10K Blue... Probably around 20-30K Yes, I know I said some insane prices, but that is what I honestly think! Please don't do this JaGex PL0x... It would make summoning THE fastest skill to get to 99 if you had all the cash for it
November 1, 200817 yr gold: 1201gp green: 4953gp blue: 38812gp crimson: 15568gp Put this in your signature if you like bagelsWII ftw!
November 2, 200817 yr No, bursting for charms would serve no purpose, as you could just buy charms. Exactly. This would fully kill the diy-attitude in summoning: it would be useless to spend even hundreds of millions on runes when you can get the charms faster and cheaper. I'm quite sure that there wouldn't be enough supply for crims and blues to find an equilibrium from those prices listed above. I place this assumption on the fact that they would mainly be passively collected: doing active waterfiends wouldn't give you a good gp:time:efford ratio and bursting is totally out of question. This lefts us with opinions like slayer. And secondaries would shoot up. I'd say there would first be a nice jump in prices and they'd come down to the point where they were ~20% more than now. The way how secondaries are being used, the biggest jump would happen in materials that are already produced in masses (yak hides, plates, etc) or in materials that won't be needed for a huge number of xp. I'd rather die for what I believe in than live for anything else.Name Removed by Administrator ~Turtlefemm
November 2, 200817 yr That would be very sweet if they did. gold: 1k gp green: 1k gp blue: 10k gp crimson: 5k gp
November 2, 200817 yr That would be very sweet if they did. gold: 1k gp green: 1k gp blue: 10k gp crimson: 5k gp No...it would be terrible. Gold : 700gp Green : 800gp Crimson : 5 - 8k gp Blue : 12k
November 4, 200817 yr Author i didnt say it would be good if they were i kno thaqt would be stupid i only asked how much they would be... Joined RS Dec 24th 2004.99 Hunter 14.08.09 10084th99 Cooking 17.06.11 188188th << Drum and Bass
November 4, 200817 yr If they were tradeable, Summoning would just be thrown in the bin with cooking, and fletching that would be easily buyable. It would also be unbalanced as people would be able to buy combat lvls. <---Please click him and you get a cookie!
Create an account or sign in to comment