What weapon would you choose???

[n8myton]

Throwing knives? That way rangers could raise ranged lvls without having to BUY everthing. (no F2P fletching :()

[youhave1236]

An abyssal whip...or a dds...

[T. Skill]

I gotta go with the DDS :twisted:

[gamblingfool]

I'm F2P and I'd like to see Rune hallys come into F2P.

 

 

 

Yea, I was wondering if these were F2P. I would go with the hallys or a granite maul.

[jessica1608]

not dragon items IMO. the granite maul is the best option i think.

 

 

 

however, i also think that none of them should be made F2P- isn't that the whole point.

[n_odie]

Wow!!! Thanks for the replys. I would say the dds is kinda much but g maul would be cool as well as hallys. Throwing knifes would be an awsome thing to intro for rangers. Once again thanks for the replys!!! :-({|=

[Indizle]

How about an Obsidian weapon (maul perhaps?) Its more powerful than most rune, yet has no special, avoiding problems of the g maul, and still keeps dragon members only.

[pker683]

d long, not g maul cause JaGeX would have to nerf the spec. also f2p pkers would finally get their att up, unless they like their rune scimmy/2h combo over it.

 

 

 

edit:throwing knifes would help range a ton, not that many mems even use them, how many p2p pures are there? im guessing less than 100k.

[Risen_The]

Umm.. maybe yew short and rune arrows?

[n_odie]

d long, not g maul cause JaGeX would have to nerf the spec. also f2p pkers would finally get their att up, unless they like their rune scimmy/2h combo over it.

 

 

 

edit:throwing knifes would help range a ton, not that many mems even use them, how many p2p pures are there? im guessing less than 100k.

 

 

 

umm D long has special too but it would be a cool weapon to have on the f2p servers. I also think that to get this item there should be an extreamly hard quest that requires a ton of the f2p skills(kinda sounds like dragon slayer). I think g maul and throwing knifes.

 

 

 

N_odie :wall:

[Dilts36]

for F2p i would go with the good old rune Scimmy And for members i would go for the whip for DH. \

[dargonhuman]

Being an f2per, I don't know which p2p weapon would be best, but, as an f2per, I wouldn't want it to happen. Why? The adage, "Give them an inch and they'll take a mile" comes to mind. With the high number of "F2p needs..." threads that abound just here on Tip.it alone, giving f2pers any p2p weapon, at all, will result in the exponential increase of f2p begging, not to mention the massive flood of "This sucks" threads from disgruntled f2pers.

 

Just look at the threads created when Jagex released POHs! If f2pers are given even a seemingly insignificant p2p weapon, the beggars will be quick to demand what weapon they "deserve" to get next, which wouldn't be good for anyone.

 

 

 

--Darg--

[imaerehw14]

Being an f2per, I don't know which p2p weapon would be best, but, as an f2per, I wouldn't want it to happen. Why? The adage, "Give them an inch and they'll take a mile" comes to mind. With the high number of "F2p needs..." threads that abound just here on Tip.it alone, giving f2pers any p2p weapon, at all, will result in the exponential increase of f2p begging, not to mention the massive flood of "This sucks" threads from disgruntled f2pers.

 

Just look at the threads created when Jagex released POHs! If f2pers are given even a seemingly insignificant p2p weapon, the beggars will be quick to demand what weapon they "deserve" to get next, which wouldn't be good for anyone.

 

 

 

--Darg--

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

he has a good point. although, being f2p and p2p, i think p2p would benefit most from knives and darts. i mean, as someone pointed out, ranges do have to buy everything. they cant make anything that they weild or wear, other than plain leather. no green dhide, no arrows, no bows, no darts, no knives. this disapoints me. giving them at least the ability to make darts and knives would be a good idea. maybe a quest just as hard as the ones you need to do to be able to make it in p2p, but in the f2p areas. also, being able to craft your own green dhide would be cool. having to buy that also stinks. it would also give the green dragon hide market a boost, although, probebly more pkers.

 

 

 

But i think just knives and darts would be juft fine.

[n8myton]

Being an f2per, I don't know which p2p weapon would be best, but, as an f2per, I wouldn't want it to happen. Why? The adage, "Give them an inch and they'll take a mile" comes to mind. With the high number of "F2p needs..." threads that abound just here on Tip.it alone, giving f2pers any p2p weapon, at all, will result in the exponential increase of f2p begging, not to mention the massive flood of "This sucks" threads from disgruntled f2pers.

 

Just look at the threads created when Jagex released POHs! If f2pers are given even a seemingly insignificant p2p weapon, the beggars will be quick to demand what weapon they "deserve" to get next, which wouldn't be good for anyone.

 

 

 

--Darg--

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

he has a good point. although, being f2p and p2p, i think p2p would benefit most from knives and darts. i mean, as someone pointed out, ranges do have to buy everything. they cant make anything that they weild or wear, other than plain leather. no green dhide, no arrows, no bows, no darts, no knives. this disapoints me. giving them at least the ability to make darts and knives would be a good idea. maybe a quest just as hard as the ones you need to do to be able to make it in p2p, but in the f2p areas. also, being able to craft your own green dhide would be cool. having to buy that also stinks. it would also give the green dragon hide market a boost, although, probebly more pkers.

 

 

 

But i think just knives and darts would be juft fine.

 

 

 

The problem with giving darts to F2P is that they are part of fletching, a members skill. Plus darts on P2P require a long quest through members areas, a difficult thing to repllicate for F2P. Throwing knives on the other hand, to my knowledge, are not part of fletching and never required a quest.

 

 

 

Off Topic: I agree that it would be nice to add greed D-Hide crafting to F2P, there are already green dragons in F2P areas, but they aren't there on F2P servers. They could just add the dragons and add crafting support for their hides to F2P, which would also fulfill some people's complain for wanting a higher lvl monster.

 

 

 

Edit: Green dragons would also give F2P some decent prayer xp (dragon bones) and give F2P a reason to level crafting past 57 (Ammulet of Power) to level 63 (Green DHide Body.)

[xJakex]

Giving them a dragon dagger wouldn't be the best idea. F2p Pking would be well, ruined.

 

 

 

I can't see many problems with a lava staff, mind. Or something in that vein.

[n_odie]

Thanks for the replys. I would would have to agree. F2P should not get a new skill. I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them. I disagree on letting f2p players make green dragon hide. It would make a members crafting all the less value than it already is. Letting g dragons would let p2p get bones but thats one of the reasons i joined members was so that i could get my prayer and agillity up. I also agree on the point that if u let f2p get a little bit they will want more. The good players would be thank ful but the "not so good players" would wine. But this is also a thred about "what if" f2p could get a weapon from a p2p server.

 

 

 

N_ODIE

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[n8myton]

I think that if knifes were allowed on a f2p server that it would allow the fletching market to go up as well in the p2p worlds because they are the only ones tha caan make them.

 

N_ODIE

 

 

 

But Throwing knives are completely unrelated to Fletching, they are instead a part of smithing, an already F2P skill. The whole point, to me, of throwing knives would be to allow F2P to craft some of their own ranged equipment. (F2P Warriors can smith weapons and armour, F2P Mages can craft their own Runes (to a point), but F2P Rangers must buy everything.)

[jwrm22]

remember that they dont need vto over power the mellee in f2p...

 

 

 

rangers: full green maple short addy arrows...

 

 

 

mage: fire staff monk robes fire blast...

 

 

 

mellee: full green/ full addy / full rune rune wapon...

 

 

 

mellee can own everything if they just use full green rune scim and r2h... and if they take a bow with arrows theyll be 100% undefeat able... (f2p, 1 vs 1, pvp, same lvl)

[jwrm22]

remember that they dont need vto over power the mellee in f2p...

 

 

 

rangers: full green maple short addy arrows...

 

 

 

mage: fire staff monk robes fire blast...

 

 

 

mellee: full green/ full addy / full rune rune wapon...

 

 

 

mellee can own everything if they just use full green rune scim and r2h... and if they take a bow with arrows theyll be 100% undefeat able... (f2p, 1 vs 1, pvp, same lvl)