didnt you hav a topic with the wip? wouldnt it be easier just to post it there? either way, great job. only cc is that the background is a little plain, and needs work. not really plain, but empty, if you know what i mean.

I like your style :)

Very nice, the person you made it for will be very happy :P

Very nice, but the obby capes highlights could be done better.

Very nice, a bit confusing, but nicely done.

its fairly nice, however the style looks rather like mxm's work more on developing your own style, and dont copy other peoples work, else you just end up a copy.

 

 

 

i dont know what it is about the ice but it just doesnt really seam to fit.

 

 

 

the highlights on the staff made it look like that corigated iron wire (?) it should be smoother, not as bumpy.

 

 

 

the whip head looks to large as well.

 

 

 

the shading on the cloacks should go the other way.

 

 

 

PJB21

I cant see the mage's left hand.The whip looks a bit odd.

 

 

 

9/10

Sig is good, but whip.... its to long, and its like abby long sword or staff, not a whip.

 

Good job.

to point out couple things:

 

picture misses movement - fella' with the whip seems just to hold it there, it doesn't look like he would be whipping.

 

there are some random black dots/scratches around the picture.

 

Skull and bones are blended to terrain too much. They look more like etchings than items with dimensions.

 

Obsidian capes are made with onyx plates joined to each other, thos capes look just hairy

 

d sq is missing a dragon picture.

 

 

 

Anyways, it's still fairly good pixelwork. A cliche, but quite nice.

I like the background XD

 

 

 

Iceblock: you seem to have used overly bright colors for it, so it seems out of place in the sig overall =)

The whip and armor looks a tad bit strange but still a great job! :thumbsup: . Just curious is the ice barrage thing brushed? :-s .

Nice work, but is the person on the right a guy or a girl? because with the way you shaded it looks as if he/she has breasts.

its nice... but the cave doesnt look like a cave it looks like ice cream or something >.

I like the background XD

 

 

 

Iceblock: you seem to have used overly bright colors for it, so it seems out of place in the sig overall =)

 

 

 

HOMGPRINCESSYOUSTOLEDMYWORDS.

 

Needs a gerbil, amirite?

 

 

 

But yes;

 

• The ice does look too bright, it stands out too much. Weren't you also going to add a splashing effect around it?
   
  What's the whipper got in his hand? An ice pick?
   
  Dragon shield, but no insignia on it?
   
  Staff would look nice if it had a sort of magical effect eminating from it or something, at the moment it just looks very inactive.

Ok, a few thigs:

 

 

 

*This applies mostly to the staff but please, please, PLEASE, anti-alias parts of your sig, especially the stuff with the dark outlines

 

 

 

*The ice is too bright and (again) needs a bit of anti-aliasing around the edges.

 

 

 

*The blue guy (I assume that's rune) is over dithered. Between the anatomy and the dithering it looks like he's wearing really tight clothes, cloth clothes, not metal armour. :-s

 

 

 

*The BG is good but kinda boring. The rock is too bare and the sky seems a bit too full and 'active'