Lol yeah i want maple to be in f2p but maybe there'll be no room to put it

Of course you have to consider the level 3 autoers that would be in there has well. It has been suggested and considered many, many times, but because of the huge autoer/macroer problem it has been rejected. If there was a place with twenty yews in one area, it would just help out all of the autoers, which is the opposite of what we want to do.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

i agree with waeffel (srry for spellin ur name wrong) but trivia questions will stop macroers. the woodcutting guild would be great!!!!!!

The autoers would totally destroy it...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Imagine walking in, and all the trees are cut down due to 100 autoers :ohnoes: .

about the macroers

 

 

 

the easiest way do avoid them is to make a question like

 

 

 

"Type in the following: 12345" because autoers can't understand syntaxes

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

and this whole idea isn't great either as many people have emphasized that the entire world i a massive woodcuttign guild

support, but i like 65 or lowest requirment for enter...

nice man i will suport you!! :wink:

hold it... PPl could manuely go in the guild and then activate the autoer program... god i hate them

i support im ganna go add the underbanner now

i'd like the idea of that but there is always the threat of... THE TERRIBLE AUTOER INVASION! AHHHH!

i think 82 woodcutting is a bit high, make it like 78..

What if ur a lvl 3 skiller? Than you cant get in the guild. Thats not good.

 

 

 

And its kind of a macroers paradise. :-s

I like this idea, so I support it! It would be helpful :), although the bank would have to be accessable right next to the trees basically :P

Nice idea =D>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

my solution for lvl 3 skillers would be that they must have a total lvl around 200-400 to enter the guild so that it will be harder for macroers to enter because they'll have to train other skills to gain the total level required for entry. That should solve the autoer problem because if u think about it what autoer/macroer is going to waste time to get a higher total lvl.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

well tell me what u think about my idea :)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

thanks

it would be awesome! f2p plz???I'd support it. i wish it would come true...

Despite only having 60 woodcutting I think that it would be a good add on to runescape. I may not be able to enter it if it was put in but it is a good idea I support!

great idea i think 80 WC to enter and put a door on the bank (that auto closes at random times :P ) so autoers would have trouble getting into it.

id support if u would change the prices in shop a bit...

 

 

 

the rune axe is a bit to exspensive,the normal,the oak and the willow logs are a bit exspensive too...

My Suggestions:

 

 

 

Levels To Enter:

 

 

 

Combat - Very bad idea, there are lots of skill pures in RS, and the other skill guilds do not have combat restrictions.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Firemaking - I do NOT suggest a dual guild. I have an account with high woodcutting and level 1 firemaking. Not fair to those players. Firemaking should have its own guild right next to the woodcutting guild, possibly with a door linking them. To go in one side, you need a woodcutting level, to go in the other side, you need a firemaking level.

 

 

 

Firemaking Guild Entrance Level: 45. Maple Burning. Besides, there will be no trees in this guild. Youd have to bring your own logs. Id reccomend a bank in the firemaking guild and the woodcutting guild for easy access.

 

 

 

ADDITIONAL FOR FIREMAKING - Perhaps have a burning fire in the middle that you can toss your logs into, because if lots of people use the guild, where are they going to light their fires when the floor is covered with them?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Woodcutting - Again, Dual Guild is a BAD idea. Level 82 is way too high, none of the other guilds are this high. I'd reccomend something around 60 or 65, seeing how this is the general level for other guilds and it would be better for other players. Remember the bank

 

 

 

WoodCutting Guild Entrance Level: 60 or 65

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ADDITIONAL - I agree with the 10 minute pin - maybe increase it to 20. It is a good idea to prevent autoers. I dissagree with the trivia at the entrance. Thad just be annoying. Besides, macroers could answer the trivia, then turn on their auto.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Trees:

 

 

 

The Amount of trees you have in this guild would make it SO large, it would take alot of walking to get to each tree.

 

 

 

Magic - 8 is too high. Drop it to 5.

 

 

 

Yew - 15 again is too high. Drop it to 10

 

 

 

Maple - 30 too high. drop it to 20

 

 

 

Willow - 60 too high. Drop it to 30

 

 

 

I would also reccomend Mahogany and Teak logs for the members. perhaps put these in a separate room for them. 20 Teak, 10 mahogany.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Great idea on the woodcutting shop.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Location: Somewhere East of varrock, Push the members section back to stick this in.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Here is a simple map i whipped up. Nothing nice, just a paint image.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pink Doors : Firemaking level Needed to Enter

 

 

 

Brown Doors : Woodcutting Level needed to enter

 

 

 

Red : Toss logs into the massive pyre of flames! :P

OOOO!!!! I know! Have it so u have to go outside the WC guild to go to the bank (like if its just right outside, Literally) and then every time u enter u would have to enter a code, or answer a trivia question etc. Then, they cant just go in, turn on the autoer and go to the bank, chop, bank, chop..so on and so forth. thoughts?

woodcutting is to high, rs won't make a guild with that 'high' requirment :o

 

 

 

good idea tho :D 8/10

I gota admit, I love this idea. But as I am muted im against that Pin after not talking thing. Im sure people that dont wanna be bothred agree with me. If that to prevent autoers it work work as im sure you can get autoers that speak every minute. Mabey a lvl 80 woodcutting req would be better and not so many trees. Mabey 4 mages, 6 yews, 6 maple, 8 willow, 8 oak, and a few normal scattered around. The shop is great, not sure if i read that the shop keeper repairs axes, Im sure you wrote that down.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edit: Forgot to mention about the combat level... there should be a combat req as I no many lvl 3 skillers...

OOOO!!!! I know! Have it so u have to go outside the WC guild to go to the bank (like if its just right outside, Literally) and then every time u enter u would have to enter a code, or answer a trivia question etc. Then, they cant just go in, turn on the autoer and go to the bank, chop, bank, chop..so on and so forth. thoughts?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dont be silly! I wouldn't go there if it was like that, sure it would cut down on the macroners, but also cut down on the amount of people that go without autoing!

i like the idea of having sum sort of trivia or sumthing to open your bank, i reckon it should be like 5 numbers on your screen that you have to type in, (like wen you install a game on your pc and you have to put in the CD key) anywayz to be able to get into the guild i reckon you should have 65 wc and have to do a simple quest like .. hmm.. chop 50 yews. (coz you 65 wc, remember?) and once you've done it theres F2P and P2P sides and in the middle theres a bank with an axe shop. there should be a minigame in the members side to get tickets (like cw's) to buy axes in the axe shop.

 

 

 

eg.

 

 

 

Bronze - 2 tickets

 

 

 

Iron - 5 tickets

 

 

 

Steel - 15 tickets

 

 

 

Mithril - 30 tickets

 

 

 

Addy - 50 tickets

 

 

 

Rune - 200 tickets

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ill draw up a map soon :wink:

agree :thumbsup:

yea that would be awesome \