You chop a tree, you get woodchop xp. You light a log, you get firemaking xp. You complete a dungeon, you get dungeoneering xp. I dunno, it sounds right. Castlewarring, Fistsofguthixing, Pestcontrolling doesn't. It's also the complexity of the skill involved, the amount of aspects that are included. I feel that yes, it should be considered a skill, albeit it's a little similar to how minigames work in terms of rewards and parties, but it is a skill regardless. It brings fun to the game and I'm fine with that.