While i see alot of what the author is saying to be true. I also dis-agree with alot. For example, where it says that f2p should have level caps to 50. I think that would be a bad idea and would infact reduce the number of subscribers. Also where it says: 'Player-killing (Pking) is not only allowed, it's part of the game in many parts and while some people gravitate to that aspect alone, it can be a turn-off for those types of players that would rather have the option of doing without it at all. ' If someone who hadn't played Runescape before read that, it would generate the wrong inpression of what it's like. It's written as if there is no choice about player-killing whereas we all know that if you really want to you could play the game without ever entering the wilderness. As many of you have said, i also disagree with the 'Lasting appeal' and 'Gameplay' rating. In my opinion i don't think he has played the game enough to realise why the inventory size we have is good. (Any bigger and it would get a bit silly). Also if it had no 'Lasting appeal' Jagex would not have the millions of PAYING customers that they currently do. (and its rising!) And what a surprise, Runescape being compared to World of Warcraft.