Sick of people saying that metalcore deathcore hardcore etc

[gongusan]

"aren't true metal."

 

I wish people would stop saying this and getting all angry over it. They're not meant to be 'true metal', they're a different genre that originates from metal, they don't pretend to be 'true metal' and they aren't, so why do people rant on and on about this music not being 'true metal', when no one even declared that they are 'true metal'.

 

It's a different genre altogether, but it's roots come from metal, that's all...

 

Sorry if I aren't making any sense, this post is kind of rushed.

[Jernlov]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

[gongusan]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

 

I know they aren't, and personally, I've never heard anyone say they are, so why do people get all butthurt over it?

[Necrobean]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

 

I know they aren't, and personally, I've never heard anyone say they are, so why do people get all butthurt over it?

 

 

 

Well I know that metalcore incoorporates some elements from metal and hardcore and that the roots of hardcore are in punk.

 

 

 

I forgot what deathcore is actually, I like it though :P .

[Cyco_Reborn]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

 

I know they aren't, and personally, I've never heard anyone say they are, so why do people get all butthurt over it?

 

Because of the first of the Metal commandments: Thou shallt not call any genre which contains 'core' metal. The same applies to nu-metal.

[Kalphite]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

 

I know they aren't, and personally, I've never heard anyone say they are, so why do people get all butthurt over it?

 

Because of the first of the Metal commandments: Thou shallt not call any genre which contains 'core' metal. The same applies to nu-metal.

 

 

 

So you wouldn't call grindcore metal either?

[How2PK]

Honestly, who cares? This topic doesn't contribute anything. Discuss it with your classmates or something. But don't bore us with the 10.000th metal/genre thread. God. I get tired from this. Sorry.

[Cyco_Reborn]

But they aren't.

 

 

 

And it's ignorant teens that say they are.

 

I know they aren't, and personally, I've never heard anyone say they are, so why do people get all butthurt over it?

 

Because of the first of the Metal commandments: Thou shallt not call any genre which contains 'core' metal. The same applies to nu-metal.

 

 

 

So you wouldn't call grindcore metal either?

 

No, because true Grindcore has major punk influences. But that doesn't stop GoreGrind being metal. ;)

[Intriguing]

Metalcore and deathcore are metal. It's not an "in my opinion" thing, they just are. However, I don't really care too much when people say they aren't. I have a tendency to hate most metal-heads anyway, so them disagreeing with me doesn't make a huge difference.

[yaff2]

First off, there is no such thing as 'true metal' and i too do not get it. -core genres are sub genres and nothing more. they are not meant to be 'true metal' and people whom complain should pretty much shut up, any -core genres do not try and be metal, they are their own genre

 

 

 

i personally love more of the -core genres and im a big time metalhead. i dont see what the big fuss is. -core genres do not try to be 'true metal' they are a sub genre!

[Nom]

I'm sick of people flipping out over this subject in general. Maybe because I'm not a metalhead, unlike nearly everyone that comes to this forum, but I just don't get it. Who care what genre it is, you enjoy it or you don't.

[warri0r45]

I'm sick of people flipping out over this subject in general. Maybe because I'm not a metalhead, unlike nearly everyone that comes to this forum, but I just don't get it. Who care what genre it is, you enjoy it or you don't.

 

 

 

Exactly. It's amazing how some people are so hung up on arguing what is and isn't "metal" as if the question of whether it's good music or not means nothing to them. Just another example of completely backwards ideological thinking.

 

 

 

Anyway, whether it's a true metal genre or a fusion genre of sorts, it does have a significant basis in metal music.

[AdioLovesSquall]

lol this topic is funny.

[NoMoreDead]

I've been wondering why people refer to modern crybaby music as "Emo". Probably for the same reason people who have no idea what metal is think Korn is metal.

[Cyco_Reborn]

I've been wondering why people refer to modern crybaby music as "Emo". Probably for the same reason people who have no idea what metal is think Korn is metal.

 

People think they can make correct assumptions from the stereotypes and then they just "follow the flock, and step in sh*t". Plus, a reason that Metalcore isn't seen as Metal by the Metal Community is because it sucks.

[Necrobean]

I've been wondering why people refer to modern crybaby music as "Emo". Probably for the same reason people who have no idea what metal is think Korn is metal.

 

 

 

People don't even know real Emo music ;) . They mostly refer to either [cabbage]music or post-hardcore.

[Bauke]

Who cares about what's "true" and what not. What matters is... do I want to listen to it or not?

[assassin_696]

I don't know what it is about metal that draws in some seriously anal people who'll argue genres all night long.

[blushenka]

So....I was thinking of creating this channel where only music will be discussed. No, seriously, I am.

 

 

 

:(

[Jernlov]

I don't know what it is about metal that draws in some seriously anal people who'll argue genres all night long.

People do it to look cool and kvlt on the internet

[Azvareth]

I don't know what it is about metal that draws in some seriously anal people who'll argue genres all night long.

 

Because most metal fans are nerds.

[Zierro]

I don't know what it is about metal that draws in some seriously anal people who'll argue genres all night long.

 

Because most metal fans are nerds.

 

 

 

Lol. It's true. By the way, good to see you changed your mind about why people like certain genres.

[Azvareth]

Lol. It's true. By the way, good to see you changed your mind about why people like certain genres.

 

 

 

Been trying to formulate a response to this for the past minute. All I can seem to come up with is:

 

 

 

1. What?

 

2. Who are you?

[Zierro]

1.) Don't remember Mlbfan's nu-metal thread? Hint: "Internet psychologists are the best!"

 

 

 

2.) Zierro

[AdioLovesSquall]

How hard can it be? True metal bands usually only have demos out or one obscure album limited to 666 copies. Anything else is false and needs to eject itself from the metal world.