Untradeable Potions

[Skeptical]

Just like buckets of slime from ectofuntus should be able to.

 

THAT'S something that I agree with.

[Bearded Phil]

Jagex kept the game "balanced" on the issue of extremes when they banned them from pvp/minigames (whole other rant, kneeling to the complainers etc...) so allowing BoBs to carry them would be a fair trade from that nerfing.

 

I support and will even up the ante to say they should be notable too, I've got around 3k spec restore(4)'s that will forever be in my bank because I: 1. never use them, and 2. don't want to take the time to drop/empty all of them.

 

Also you can't split (4) potions into (2)'s so if I want to take some half filled potions on a dragon slayer task so I can drop the vials for inventory space, I better have some already because otherwise....SOL.

[K4ylan]

Just like buckets of slime from ectofuntus should be able to.

 

THAT'S something that I agree with.

 

I disagree, that's going to make the Ectofunctus way to easy and faster.

[Bladewing]

Just like buckets of slime from ectofuntus should be able to.

 

THAT'S something that I agree with.

 

I disagree, that's going to make the Ectofunctus way to easy and faster.

Although that's another topic, gilded altar would still be faster and superior, so it would just make those who have low incomes better off.

[PereGrin]

i support, and hopefully when i finally finish farming all my avantoe, you will be able to hold extremes in a BoB

[la la la]

While we are on the topic of needless restrictions, do you think jagex could speed up the grinding speed of bones? Making super prayers takes AGES, and it's not like doubling the speed of bone grinding would revolutionalize prayer training or anything...

[Artemis1330]

Man I can't stand dking with overloads and dealing with yak as well. Sure I only take ~12 brews, but I use them WHEN I need them, meaning emergencies. Just annoying. Plus I'd love to take more super prayer.

 

On the other note of ecto, currently its about 150-200 an hour bone grinding, maybe 250, but no more. Yea that's a wide range but that is horribly slow. Just adding the ability to yak bone meal would make a significant increase, updating speed....... phew that would own. And no it would not change prices/training methods to much. Wyvern bones may go up slightly but that's it.

 

Also, like it's been said. I can already easily take enough overloads etc to last a trip to gwd/dk/etc, this would simply make it more relaxing and less annoying.

[L0rdAki]

Agreed. Familiars should be able to hold everything (Or, because no doubt i've overlooked something, at least extreme pots/nightshade). It's not like we're trading them to another player, it's an extended part of our inventory.

 

I'm happy to support if this gets taken to the RSOF, too. This needs action *picks up sign*

[stonewall337]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

 

Geez man. You didn't even read what he said, or else you didn't understand it. Neither says much for your intelligence. Blade said that xpots should be able to be placed in your BoB's inventory. Nothing else. Doing so does not necessitate making them tradable to others...

[Kata_Phfract__the_slayer]

although i cant use any of the untradeible potions i can see what you mean, and it does strike my as strange, and rather dumb.

 

exstrieam potions should be bob storeable, at least to an point.

 

and while there at it make buckets of slime and a few other items like that bob storeable.

[Assume Nothing]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

 

Geez man. You didn't even read what he said, or else you didn't understand it. Neither says much for your intelligence. Blade said that xpots should be able to be placed in your BoB's inventory. Nothing else. Doing so does not necessitate making them tradable to others...

 

Seeing the posts he made on this thread, it's reasonable to say he's pretty dumb. Anyways - Jagex really needs to listen to our ideas. =/

[Dire_Wolf]

I agree, and there's many other items that should also be storeable. For example perfect shells from tortoises.

[bedman]

JJu, just admit you were either wrong, or completely off the point. He doesn't want them to become tradeable to everyone. He's not going to get faster kills an hour. He just wants a more user friendly game. That's it, that's all.

[Assume Nothing]

JJu, just admit you were either wrong, or completely off the point. He doesn't want them to become tradeable to everyone. He's not going to get faster kills an hour. He just wants a more user friendly game. That's it, that's all.

Why argue with someone so stubborn/arrogant/dumb to realise that they are wrong? It's pointless

 

Back on topic - I'd love to see the update actually happen, just a question of time eh :(

[applyapple]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

Jagex made them untradable for a reason. If Extremes were to suddenly become tradeable, then Super Attack, Super Strength, etc. potions would be deemed as weak and feeble in comparison.

 

...

 

Think of the untradeable holiday rares. If Jagex made the Bunny Ears and Scyte tradeable then that would just be another way for people to gain ridiculous amounts of money based on luck (where you had to be there when they were dropped). They quit doing the tradeable holiday rares, and I'm not going to write an entire essay of it here.

 

1) You aren't responding to anything in my thread. Please make your own thread if you want to write about these things.

2) I never suggested these potions be made tradeable.

3) How about you give a better counterargument than "making things harder and more annoying is good", because it's pretty weak.

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

I'm not offended, your arguments are just weak, impertinent, and/or just false. If you have something legitimate, post it.

 

Lol, totally agree + support your thread. Why untradeable potions aren't allowed in a familiar is beyond me. I know it's untradeable therefore it couldn't be, but beyond that reasoning there is nothing else.

They are droppable, correct?

Otherwise you could drop an undroppable item (by storing then dismissing).

[Assume Nothing]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

Jagex made them untradable for a reason. If Extremes were to suddenly become tradeable, then Super Attack, Super Strength, etc. potions would be deemed as weak and feeble in comparison.

 

...

 

Think of the untradeable holiday rares. If Jagex made the Bunny Ears and Scyte tradeable then that would just be another way for people to gain ridiculous amounts of money based on luck (where you had to be there when they were dropped). They quit doing the tradeable holiday rares, and I'm not going to write an entire essay of it here.

 

1) You aren't responding to anything in my thread. Please make your own thread if you want to write about these things.

2) I never suggested these potions be made tradeable.

3) How about you give a better counterargument than "making things harder and more annoying is good", because it's pretty weak.

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

I'm not offended, your arguments are just weak, impertinent, and/or just false. If you have something legitimate, post it.

 

Lol, totally agree + support your thread. Why untradeable potions aren't allowed in a familiar is beyond me. I know it's untradeable therefore it couldn't be, but beyond that reasoning there is nothing else.

They are droppable, correct?

Otherwise you could drop an undroppable item (by storing then dismissing).

 

Eh? If you mean undroppable item shouldn't be stored in a familiar, then fine, but extreme potions should be storable, there's no reason not to.

[applyapple]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

Jagex made them untradable for a reason. If Extremes were to suddenly become tradeable, then Super Attack, Super Strength, etc. potions would be deemed as weak and feeble in comparison.

 

...

 

Think of the untradeable holiday rares. If Jagex made the Bunny Ears and Scyte tradeable then that would just be another way for people to gain ridiculous amounts of money based on luck (where you had to be there when they were dropped). They quit doing the tradeable holiday rares, and I'm not going to write an entire essay of it here.

 

1) You aren't responding to anything in my thread. Please make your own thread if you want to write about these things.

2) I never suggested these potions be made tradeable.

3) How about you give a better counterargument than "making things harder and more annoying is good", because it's pretty weak.

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

I'm not offended, your arguments are just weak, impertinent, and/or just false. If you have something legitimate, post it.

 

Lol, totally agree + support your thread. Why untradeable potions aren't allowed in a familiar is beyond me. I know it's untradeable therefore it couldn't be, but beyond that reasoning there is nothing else.

They are droppable, correct?

Otherwise you could drop an undroppable item (by storing then dismissing).

 

Eh? If you mean undroppable item shouldn't be stored in a familiar, then fine, but extreme potions should be storable, there's no reason not to.

I agree. Just clarifying, as my herblore is only 55.

[JacTise69]

So what bladewing. Why don't you tell me right now to leave your topic so you can continue to search for more supporters instead of telling me that I did not read your measly "7 WORDS."

Jagex made them untradable for a reason. If Extremes were to suddenly become tradeable, then Super Attack, Super Strength, etc. potions would be deemed as weak and feeble in comparison.

 

...

 

Think of the untradeable holiday rares. If Jagex made the Bunny Ears and Scyte tradeable then that would just be another way for people to gain ridiculous amounts of money based on luck (where you had to be there when they were dropped). They quit doing the tradeable holiday rares, and I'm not going to write an entire essay of it here.

 

1) You aren't responding to anything in my thread. Please make your own thread if you want to write about these things.

2) I never suggested these potions be made tradeable.

3) How about you give a better counterargument than "making things harder and more annoying is good", because it's pretty weak.

 

If you are that offended by my opinion, you are making a mountain out of a mole hole.

 

I'm not offended, your arguments are just weak, impertinent, and/or just false. If you have something legitimate, post it.

 

I agree. Lmfao @ jjustin. Your going off on him without even reading the post. [bleep]ing [developmentally delayed] XD

 

Don't judge who I am when it's a living fact you don't even know me. Either post nicely or get out of Rants.

 

we very well can judge who you are. it doesn't matter that we haven't met you physically, you've demonstrated qualities we find undesirable, and which require no physical interaction to understand. it is based on those qualities (inability/unwillingness to acknowledge your mistakes, as well as the initial arrogance of posting without reading the topic) that we are judging you.

 

you made a post which was off topic. either you did not read the post, or you misunderstood it.

 

you could have stopped there, and admitted your mistake, but instead you have decided to fight us, defending your post as an opinion which thusly can't be judged, whereas we are saying that even if it is an opinion, it is completely unrelated. we are not telling you to keep your opinions to yourself, we are telling you to keep your opinions relevant.

 

 

Jagex made them untradable for a reason. If Extremes were to suddenly become tradeable, then Super Attack, Super Strength, etc. potions would be deemed as weak and feeble in comparison.

 

If you want to argue that BoB should bank Extremes for faster kills at TDs or God Wars, then you might find yourself on the winning side. I feel that Supers are good enough, whether people on here think so or not.

 

Think of the untradeable holiday rares. If Jagex made the Bunny Ears and Scyte tradeable then that would just be another way for people to gain ridiculous amounts of money based on luck (where you had to be there when they were dropped). They quit doing the tradeable holiday rares, and I'm not going to write an entire essay of it here.

 

My view on this is that Jagex will eventually allow Extremes to be bankable for BoBs. It will be introduced in a major update that will be included with other tweaks/minor updates. Extreme potions will make killing monsters faster and easier than what Super potions did. There is a difference. Thus, the game has to be BALANCED. Making Extremes tradeable and possibly bankable in BoBs will make the game easier. Just admit it.

 

I don't support.

 

in your original post. it starts by saying that jagex had motivations for keeping the potions untradeable. this is a fact which jagex made public with the update, and the reason is this: they wanted to provide benefits to high-level herbalists.

 

original newspost about the potions: http://services.runescape.com/m=news/newsitem.ws?id=2288&allcat=true

 

your second line, which i have put in bold, is where it is clear that you did not read the topic.

 

If you want to argue that BoB should bank Extremes

 

he was saying that beasts of burden should be able to 'bank' extremes [untradeable potions]. you just told him that if he wanted to say the thing that he just did say, then he might be right.

 

obviously you did not understand or overlooked his original intent, because you would not be advising someone to argue a point, which they are already arguing.

 

your next few lines go on to talk about rares or something irrelevant, a further indication that you missed the point completely.

 

your last few lines are substantial and if you had posted only them, you wouldn't be getting all this criticism. however, your last sentence or two are:

 

Thus, the game has to be BALANCED. Making Extremes tradeable and possibly bankable in BoBs will make the game easier. Just admit it.

 

i am pretty sure he already has implied that being able to store extremes in beasts of burden will make things easier. that is why he wants it to be done. when you ask him to 'admit it' you again seem to have missed his point.

 

then your last line

 

I don't support.

 

you've just said that you think beasts of burden will eventually be able to carry extremes, which is what the OP wants, and what his post is saying should happen. why then do you say you don't support his post?

 

 

okay?

 

^

this