Hmm...that's a hard one.

 

 

 

A scyth would be cool, cause there's absolutely no way to get it again (unlike the party hat...well for me i wouldn't be able to get a phat cause it's so freakin expensive..)

 

 

 

And if you die with a scyth you can get it agian. (i think?) As if you died with a phat, your pretty much screwed.

 

 

 

But to have a phat, you're either a really old Runescape player or crazy rich.

 

 

 

Man, i'd take both! :mrgreen:

Phat, I had the best time that Halloween period when they were released and not having a scythe reminds me of that time.

I'm lucky enough to have both of them. :) I' take another partyhat, some color which I don't have now: blue, red, yellow or purple.

I got a scythe. I used to have a phat.

 

So I'm obviously going to choose the thing I don't got...

i have both :)

 

 

 

prefer phat

 

can sell it for skills :P

Id trade my scythe for a p hat =)

i got both but i will choise party hat as its the best thing to be annoyed on f2p by low lvls

I'd rather have the scythe, if I die I can get another one! :D

 

 

 

Plus I think it would look cool.