POSTED AND CREDITED! Charms drops topic 1 (Locked)

[roeltjeuh]

Disregard this post.

[Shadow_Clawe]

Welcome to the Forum for updates on Charm Drops. Any information you have please post on this thread. Credit will be given when due.

 

 

 

Because the Bestiary can't be updated directly on Tip.it, I guess this is the way it will have to be done...

 

 

 

Any information regarding:

 

 

 

Which monsters drop charms (Try to include the Level of the monster)

 

Which color charms that specific monster drops

 

 

 

How many charms of that specific color dropped at one time

 

 

 

How many kills of that monster it takes to get a specified charm (Just tell how many time you killed it, and how many times you got which charms.)

 

 

 

Should be posted on this thread, and you will be given credit if you were first to post it.

 

 

 

You won't need to submit all this information, any information you have would be great to us!

 

 

 

If you keep track of the probability, post how many kills you got, and how many charms you got. Percentage won't be much help to us, as we need to add how many kills and charms EVERYONE got.

 

 

 

(# of charms dropped at once, [#of charms/# of kills])

 

 

 

 

 

Jan 15 4:30 ET - Chaos Dwarves Level 48 drops Green Charm (1), Gold Charm (1), and Blue Charm (1).

 

 

 

Jan 15 4:53 ET - Level 28 Hill Giants drop Gold Charm (1), and Blue Charm (1). ----- 4:57 ET - + Green Charm (1).

 

 

 

Level 61 Basilisks drop Gold Charm (1), Crimson charm (1), and Green Charm (1). (Thanks Sophia1900!)

 

 

 

Jan 15 5:53 ET - Level 53 Ice Giants drop Gold Charm (1). ---- 6:22 ET - + Blue Charm (1).

 

 

 

Jan 15 6:29 ET - Level 57 Ice Warriors drop Crimson Charm (1), and Gold Charm (1).

 

 

 

Baby Black Dragon Level 83 Drops Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). -------(Thanks Aoe325!)

 

 

 

Ice Spider Level 61 drops Green Charm (1). ----(Thanks SprBean!)

 

 

 

Level 53 Jogre drops Gold (1), and Green (1). ---- (Thanks SprBean!)

 

 

 

Level 53 Ogre drops Green (1), and Crimson (1). -----(Thanks zeleen!)

 

 

 

Level 85 Kalphite soldier drops Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). -----(Thanks Matok!)

 

 

 

Level 246 Steel Dragon drops Gold (3), Green (3), and Crimson (3). -----(Thanks roeltjeuh!)

 

 

 

Level 92 Greater Demon drops Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). ----(Thanks Jamie_r0x!)

 

 

 

Level 41 Abyssal Leech drops Green (1). ------(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 81 Abyssal Walker drops Green (1). -------(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 59 Abyssal Guardian drops Green (1), Abyssal (1). ------(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 34 Deadly Red Spider drops Gold (1, 27%), Crimson (1). -----(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 42 Moss Giant drops Gold (1), Green (1). ---(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 137 Giant Rock Crab drops Gold (10), Green (10), Crimson (10). -----(Thanks mage_hat!)

 

 

 

Level 19 Khazard trooper drops Gold (1, [2/25]), Green (1), Crimson (1, [2/25])-----(Thanks johnnunn123!)

 

 

 

Jan 17 3:06 ET - Level 21 Guards drop Gold (1).

 

 

 

Jan 17 3:31 ET - Level 6 Bats drop Gold (1, [12/110]).

 

 

 

Level 89 Turoth drops Gold (1, [17/168]), Green (1, [38/168]), Crimson (1, [6/168]), Blue (1, [2/168]) ------- (Thanks snick5!)

 

 

 

Wall Beast level 49 drops Gold (1, [5/40]), Green (1, [1/40]), Crimson (1, [9/15]) -------(Thanks dinak66!)

 

 

 

Lvl 74 Dagganoths: 1 Gold (possible green but rare from the 74's) ------(Thanks Obsidiaqueen!)

 

 

 

Lvl 92 Dagganoths: 1 Gold; 1 Crimson; 1 Green; 1 Blue ------(Thanks Obsidiaqueen!)

 

 

 

Dark Warriors level 8 drop Gold (1, [10/100]), Crimson (1, [2/100]) ------ (Thanks Rosebuster17!)

 

 

 

shadow warrior (lvl 48): gold charm (1), green charm (1), crimson charm (1)

 

and Blue charm (1) ----- (Thanks TiKRuy!)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Please do not copy my work.

 

 

 

Monster -- Level -- Charm drops

 

 

 

Bat -- 6 -- Gold (1, [12/110])



Khazard trooper -- 19 -- Gold (1, [2/25]), Green (1), Crimson (1, [2/25])-----(Thanks johnnunn123!)



Guard -- 21 -- Gold (1)



Hill Giant -- 28 -- Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1)



Deadly Red Spider -- 34 -- Gold (1, 27%), Crimson (1). -----(Thanks mage_hat!)



Abyssal Leech -- 41 -- Gold (1), Green (1) ----(Thanks mage_hat!)



Moss Giant -- 42 -- Gold (1), Green (1). ---(Thanks mage_hat!)



Chaos Dwarf -- 48 -- Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1)



Wall Beast -- 49 -- Gold (1, [5/40]), Green (1, [1/40]), Crimson (1, [9/15]) -------(Thanks dinak66!)



Ice Giant -- 53 -- Gold (1), Blue (1)



Jogre -- 53 -- Gold (1),  (1). ---- (Thanks SprBean!)



Ogre -- 53 -- Green (1), and Crimson (1). -----(Thanks zeleen!)



Ice Warrior -- 57 -- Gold (1), Crimson (1)



Abyssal Guardian -- 59 -- Green (1), Abyssal (1). ------(Thanks mage_hat!)



Basilisk -- 61 -- Gold (1),  Green (1), Crimson (1) ---------(Thanks Sophia1900!)



Ice Spider -- 61 -- Green Charm (1). ----(Thanks SprBean!)



Abyssal Walker -- 81 -- Green (1). -------(Thanks mage_hat!)



Baby Black Dragon -- 83 -- Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). -------(Thanks Aoe325!)



Kalphite Soldier -- 85 -- Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). -------(Thanks Matok!)



Turoth -- 89 -- Gold (1, [17/168]), Blue (1, [2/168]), Green (1, [38/168]), Crimson (1, [6/168]) --------(Thanks snick5!)



Greater Demon -- 92 -- Gold (1), Blue (1), Green (1), and Crimson (1). --------(Thanks Jamie_r0x!)



Giant Rock Crab -- 137 -- Gold (10), Green (10), Crimson (10). -----(Thanks mage_hat!)



Steel Dragon -- 246 -- Gold (3), Green (3), Crimson (3). -----(Thanks roeltjeuh!)

[runswithsciz]

lvl ? wolves (those on white wolf mountain) drops green charms (1)

 

gimme credit :D

[Ginger_Warrior]

I have a theory: If a monster drops one colour of charm, it will drop all four colours of charm.

 

 

 

If someone could confirm this one way or another, it would help us on the Bestiary massively. For instance, do Chaos Dwarves drop Crimson charms? Do Basilisks actually drop Blue charms?

 

 

 

For those interested, I've decided to call all drops as "Charm(#)" instead of their actual colours.

[Shadow_Clawe]

lvl ? wolves (those on white wolf mountain) drops green charms (1)

 

gimme credit :D

 

 

 

There are wolves of more than one level on White Wolf Mt. You will need to know which exact level.

 

 

 

Hmm interesting theory, Ginger. It could be possible, but not likely Level 28 Hill Giants drop Obsidian Charms?

 

I mean, anythings possible, maybe like an extremely rare drop for the lower levels. Oh yeah, I'll add to the top that anyone with information and preferrably proof (Screenshots) should post here and I'll give credit where it's due.

[tryto]

I agree with Ginger, excluding Obsidian Charms, those seem to be exclusively tzhaar. But, I've seen a couple of threads where people claim to be getting a clear increase of certain colours from specific monsters(eg crimson from shadow warriors).

 

 

 

EDIT: Also, "Gold" charms seem to be the most common of the charms for most monsters, probably because they're the lowest level ones. Here is a useful thread on this.

[Malhavok]

Charms: gold-1, green-1, crimson 1, blue-1

 

 

 

spirit seed - 1

[aoe325]

I have a theory: If a monster drops one colour of charm, it will drop all four colours of charm.

 

 

 

If someone could confirm this one way or another, it would help us on the Bestiary massively. For instance, do Chaos Dwarves drop Crimson charms? Do Basilisks actually drop Blue charms?

 

 

 

For those interested, I've decided to call all drops as "Charm(#)" instead of their actual colours.

 

 

 

I found some monsters drop alot more of a certain kind.

 

 

 

For instance I heard fire giants rarely drop anything then gold

 

 

 

While Baby black dragon (level-83) drops gold, crimson, blue, and green at a perfectly equal rate. 1 at a time

 

 

 

Since what players want to know is not what monster drops what we should have a frequency system to show how often you can explain a drop

 

 

 

Gold charm (++) or something :anxious:

[SprBean]

Ice Spider(lvl 61) --> Green Charm(1)

 

Jogre(lvl 53) --> Gold Charm(1), Green Charm(1)

 

Earth Warriors(lvl 51) --> Gold Charm(1), Crimson Charm(1)

 

Zamorak Warrior(lvl 85) --> Gold Charm(1)

 

Giant crypt rat (lvl 76) --> Green Charm(1)

 

Possesed Pickaxe(lvl 50)--> Gold Charm(1)

 

I'll edit my post if i Find more

[zeleen]

Ogre lvl 53 --> Green Charm (1), Crimson Charm (1)

[runswithsciz]

hill giant lvl 28 -> gold charm [1]

[pokemama]

For those interested, I've decided to call all drops as "Charm(#)" instead of their actual colours.

 

 

 

I found some monsters drop alot more of a certain kind.

 

...

 

Since what players want to know is not what monster drops what we should have a frequency system to show how often you can explain a drop

 

 

 

Gold charm (++) or something :anxious:

 

 

 

+1, I hate the work it entails for the Crew but I have to agree. People are gonna want to know if they will get 93 gold charms, 3 red, 3 green and 1 blue as opposed to 0 gold, 50 red, 50 green, 0 blue.

 

 

 

I have no idea how this will really play out in practicality (actual distributions of drops) ... I suggest using something that can be search/replaced (so a variable symbol like # isn't ideal).

[Clan_Chat_Op]

well let me start it off

 

 

 

Dust Devils:

 

 

 

about 40% drop ratio for charms in the following ratio

 

 

 

8:4:2:1

 

crimson>gold>green>blue

[Shadow_Clawe]

For those interested, I've decided to call all drops as "Charm(#)" instead of their actual colours.

 

 

 

I found some monsters drop alot more of a certain kind.

 

...

 

Since what players want to know is not what monster drops what we should have a frequency system to show how often you can explain a drop

 

 

 

Gold charm (++) or something :anxious:

 

 

 

+1, I hate the work it entails for the Crew but I have to agree. People are gonna want to know if they will get 93 gold charms, 3 red, 3 green and 1 blue as opposed to 0 gold, 50 red, 50 green, 0 blue.

 

 

 

I have no idea how this will really play out in practicality (actual distributions of drops) ... I suggest using something that can be search/replaced (so a variable symbol like # isn't ideal).

 

 

 

Yes very interesting. Researching that would be a lot harder than researching what I'm doing now, but it would be impossible to research the drop rate when we don't know which charms they actually drop. Sorry if I'm just kinda starting out slow here, hope this information would still come of use to you.

[Matok]

Finished a ~200 Kalphites task on the soldiers (level 85)

 

Not the best drop rate...

 

anyway they drop gold,green,blue,crimson charms, 1 at the time.

 

 

 

the distribution is about

 

2:1:1:1

 

gold>green>blue>crimson

[roeltjeuh]

(Edit:) How did you become the author... O well I guess since were correcting the same update 8-) (/Edit)

 

 

 

Mayby cause i was before you? :P

 

 

 

Litle more update:

 

Steel dragon:

 

4x Green (3 in 1 drop)

 

4x crimson (also 3)

 

2x gold (3)

 

 

 

(dunno about blue, only killed 15)

[Lanze_eriee]

wolves (lvl64) drop crimson charms as well

[Ginger_Warrior]

Yes very interesting. Researching that would be a lot harder than researching what I'm doing now, but it would be impossible to research the drop rate when we don't know which charms they actually drop. Sorry if I'm just kinda starting out slow here, hope this information would still come of use to you.

 

Absolutely not. The work you are doing here will be of huge help later on. This is exactly the research technique we like from the community. :)

[roeltjeuh]

Absolutely not. The work you are doing here will be of huge help later on. This is exactly the research technique we like from the community. :)

 

 

 

So what do you exactly want us to do now? (if we want to offcourse :P)

 

what color of charm they drop or also the drop rate?

[no_way2go]

Infernal mages also drop green, gold and crimson charms.

 

Just had them as a slayer assignment: 2 green, 2 crimson and 8 golds in 48 kills while wearing a ring of wealth.

[Ginger_Warrior]

Absolutely not. The work you are doing here will be of huge help later on. This is exactly the research technique we like from the community. :)

 

 

 

So what do you exactly want us to do now? (if we want to offcourse :P)

 

what color of charm they drop or also the drop rate?

 

My role on Tip.It isn't to guide you guys, it's to guide the data you gather yourselves and provide us into a presentable format on the Tip.It Bestiary.

 

 

 

Go about your everyday RS lives. If you find a monster that drops charms, tell us how many charms that monster drops compared to how many of them you killed. That would help massively. :

[Scampioen]

lesser demons: 2 green and a gold, but uncommon

[Irish_Geek]

Ice warriors drop gold, green, crimson, and blue

 

 

 

after about 25k exp, i got 47gold, 3green, 1crimson, and 1blue

[pedrahm5]

bloodvelds drop all four kinds, but they seem to drop green the most, followed by gold.

 

 

 

 

 

abby specs drop all four as well, but pretty evenly distributed. Because of this they're one of the better not-so-high-lvl sources of blue charms I've found so far.

[Shadow_Clawe]

Guys, before you post make sure no one posted the same thing before you.