August 11, 200817 yr Let's say i say this to a person in public chat Can i ask where your from? That's asking personal details, but the "Can"
August 11, 200817 yr I'd say no. Because of Jagex's apparently terrible banning system for that sort of thing, and to be honest, it just sounds a bit more polite, rather than a different question altogether.
August 11, 200817 yr Well the answer to that would be "YES" or "NO" wouldn't it? Then you would have to ask the question "where are you from?" In my opinion it's ok, whenever i'm asked the question i would say the region of the country i'm from. Thank you to tripsis for an awesome sig!
August 11, 200817 yr Who are we to say they can or cant give marks, There is nobody who works for Jagex here.
August 11, 200817 yr If someone specifically reported you for this; then Jagex can punish you. But no-one has the nerve to report for tiddy things like that; so you should be ok. Most of my mates no where I live; and I know where they live; so its not such a big deal.. Just keep your fingers crossed. ;) - Rem. :P Please visit our forums !! Click the link!! Register; and get posting!CLICK! ---> http://dantay800.com/forum1/index.php <---CLICK!
August 11, 200817 yr I wouldn't of thought so, but I don't think many people know what Jagex do and do not accept. I wouldn't experiment though.
August 11, 200817 yr I'd say yes just to be on the safe side and Jagex is only protecting the user. As said previously they are the judge it really depends which jagex moderator handles the situation. Proud Tip.It Moderator December 07 - October 2009Proud TETAU Member 2006 - 2007 <3"I had a standing agreement with god. I'd agree to believe in him, barely, so long as he let me sleep in on Sundays." - Rose Hathaway[ Posting & You ] [ Forum Rules ] [ Next Tetau Event ]
August 11, 200817 yr Author Ive been wondering on this, and btw Remadin, i know my friends name and stuff. But it's still reportable But that's stinks , that even this can be reported for -.-
August 11, 200817 yr Who knows? Jagex decides to ban this sort of crap on regular basis. 2257AD.TUMBLR.COM
August 11, 200817 yr "what would you say if I asked you where are you from?" isnt reportable. "i would say I am from USA" or "I would say you are not allowed to ask that" or "I would report you" < hate such noobs My goals: [b]5M coins:[/b] 4350K+ coins 200k+ items - 2 dec 5M coins - 16 dec I [b]have gotten[/b] my 5M by christmas. -bah this is only here for historical purposes now, I got 20m+ already "fail,well atleast the title,i wont read it with that colours""If you hadn't posted in rainbow I would actually give this a proper read""Colours suck."*I remove colours*"Where did all the colors go!? This is now 40% more likely to be tl;dr'd due to the lack of colors."
August 11, 200817 yr They can. I'd only ask someone if they've proven to be an obviously good enough friend. catch it now so you can like it before it went so mainstream
August 11, 200817 yr Yeah they most likely would, even though it's stupid. Just be like I'm from Canada how bout you? Come to #tip-it on Swift IRC, if you're cool
August 12, 200817 yr I've heard from mods that this is acceptable, but actually asking where can earn you a shiny black mark. Corporeal Drops:2xHoly elixersBandos Drops: Bcp(soloed) 5x hilts 8x tassets Armadyl Drops:Armadyl Hilt(trio)Zamorak Drops: 2xZamorakian spear 3x Steam battlestaff
August 12, 200817 yr If someone specifically reported you for this; then Jagex can punish you. But no-one has the nerve to report for tiddy things like that; so you should be ok. Most of my mates no where I live; and I know where they live; so its not such a big deal.. Just keep your fingers crossed. ;) - Rem. :P Don't be so sure, I got reported because someone said they lived not too far from where i was, i asked where abouts after they did and I got a black mark for it. People will report you for anything, they probs just wanna be PMs. lol. Looking for a clan!
August 12, 200817 yr There is a topic in RSOF called "The Reporting Academy", I believe this should answer your question but unfortunately the topic of "Asking for Personal Details" is currently under construction. I believe you can ask a question to one of the Mods after they are done .
August 12, 200817 yr I think the question you should be asking is "Once I have been banned after asking 'Can i ask where your from?', what should I write in my appeal. The fact of the matter is that, even though this is an indirect question asking to ask a question, it can still lead to the real deal. I don't think Jagex would even think twice about giving you a mark because they want to keep the game secure. The more secure the game, the more parents buy membership for their 6 year old kid. The more membership, the more money. The more money, the better updates. So yes, you would get a black mark.
August 12, 200817 yr It depends on the situation. If you ask "What country do you live in?", then it should not really be an offensive, but if you go into further detail such as town/superb then it should be reported. Why? Because younger players could give out information without thinking about the consequences. My relaxation method involves a bottle of lotion, beautiful women, and partial nudity. Yes I get massages.
August 12, 200817 yr Let's say i say this to a person in public chat Can i ask where your from? That's asking personal details, but the "Can" Yes, but you're saying that, should the answer be yes, your next question is "where are you from". I would try to be more specific. Stick to something broad, like country or state, that couldn't possibly be used to identify someone. I doubt Jagex would fear you tracking someone if they said "Oh I live in Montana" or the likes.
August 12, 200817 yr Let's say i say this to a person in public chat Can i ask where your from? That's asking personal details, but the "Can" No, I think you were just being polite or curious. It wasn't as if you were going all Michael Jackson on them. :lol: So, basically Earthysun is Jesus's only son.
Create an account or sign in to comment