Whip Drop Rates

[Juader]

Ja,

I have done 17 Abyssal Demon tasks now, gotten _3_ whips.

Of these tasks I have done 16 in Abyssal Plane and one in Tower

 

I have gotten _1_ Whip in the Abyssal Plane and 2 in Tower

 

So my question is, does the drop rate really have THAT big difference in places? Or is it just my crappy luck.

 

If so, I will do tasks in Tower from this moment onwards.

[Zephy]

Sounds like you're just suffering from a small sample size, especially for the tower. They're the exact same monsters, and what I've read from other people's logs sounds like they have the same rate.

[Kiriyama]

Yeah..

 

Drop rates are a chance to drop..You just got some good luck at the tower and got 2 drops. There's no difference.

[Solartide]

I have done maybe 40 strykewyrm tasks, of all kinds, and gotten 1 hexcrest.

[SirIzenhime]

the only situation were drop rates are altered is the charm rates of monsters in the Chaos Tunnel compared to those out of the tunnel. Otherwise it's just random luck.

[ghjkl]

No it is always 1 in 400.

[L0rdAki]

As a side note, do them in Kura's dungeon. I can't see your combat levels, but unless you're a Mage/rage fanatic you should be 110+ combat.

Drops are random.

[Soulthresher]

I've camped the Abbyys in the tower for roughly 7-8 hours straight and only got one whip drop from that.

 

I've had 2 Abby tasks which I completed in Kuradel's dungeon and got a whip drop.

 

I would say its just your luck. Slayer monsters seem to have relatively consistent drops as far as their specific drops. Then again, you could go kill Graador once and recieve a hilt against guys who mass there for hours straight, day after day and not recieve a drop. It's all a numbers game.

[Bladewing]

I'm going to assume you use Duradel since you aren't in Kuradal's cave.

 

17 tasks at a 165 average would be 2800 kills. In 2800 kills, the odds of getting n whips is:

 

0 whips - 0.2%

1 whips - 1.2%

2 whips - 3.8%

3 whips - 8.0%

4 whips - 12.4%

5 whips - 15.4%

6 whips - 16.0% (expected number)

7+ whips - 43.0%

 

You are only among the 13.2% most unlucky. One in eight players will be as unlucky as you.

[SirIzenhime]

Wow, I'm so unlucky then, I've only ever gotten 3 whip drops :blink:

[Quorra]

21 whip drops here

 

2 in tower, 19 in the abyss place.

[Neltak]

Oo I just realized how unlucky I am...15 tasks (averaging around 200/task) dry.

[SirIzenhime]

95 slayer with 3 whips....demons hate me <_<

[Bladewing]

A dry streak doesn't mean your luck is bad. Say I do 100 abyssal demon tasks. You have almost a 40% chance of going 10 tasks or more dry.

[lagatag]

Why not in Kuradel's dungeon? Are you not 110 combat? I find that highly unlikely if you're 85 slayer.

[Saru Inc]

I get a whip a task or more,sometimes 3 whips per task

[salim123]

It's really just random luck abyssals seem to love me more then any other monsters tho cuz i'v gotten over 80 whips and im just about 96 slayer roughly i get a whip every 250 kills tho but its all random i'v gotten 4 whips in 1 task but i can go 5+ tasks without a whip

[SirIzenhime]

^ I hate you <_<