January 4, 200719 yr I've been thinking about who would win in melee combat if 2 players were to duel, one would have gear giving him best defence while the other player would have the best stats on the attack and strength of the weapon. In theory if the barrows armor is still very strong compared to the counterpart of best weapon in the game and attack bonuses added on, a player with high defence might be able to kill a player who has lower defence that has higher hitting and accuracy. Gear setup 1st player with best defence Full Torag armor Crystal shield Whip Fury ammy Rune boots dark gloves berserker ring fire cape 2nd player with best offense there can be 2 options here but the one im mainly looking for is accuracy which would help penetrate armor better so I will go with gear that gives attack bonus instead of strength Warrior helm torag plate and legs rune boots rune defender Fury ammy whip berserker ring dark gloves fire cape My bet on this would be that the 2nd player would win due to rune defender being in the picture. and that the sacrifice of lower defence provided in the shield slot by the rune defender but gives higher accuracy to whip might actualy be in favour of the 2nd player. Also this would be a good way to see if the game is still in balance or if armor has become obsolete. To test all this I need 2 players who have 99s in hp attack strength and defence and have at least everything except the ring and fury ammy. Ring might not make a big difference in the duel but I do need to make this as fair as possible given the items available in the game. So if one player doesnt have the ring then the other shouldnt use it. As far as fury goes, both players should have furies or substitute it with glory.
January 4, 200719 yr Best RFD gloves are the Barrow/Dark Gloves. Hmmm... I always thought best offence would be: Dharok Helm Dharok Plate Dharok Legs Dharok Greataxe Fire Cape Fury Amulet Berserker Ring Rune Boots Barrows/Dark Gloves As to who would win? I'd personally say best offence. "A good offence is a good defence." ^Click to see Blog^232/232 Quest Points, 99/99 Firemaking99/99 Fletching, 98/99 Cooking43/99 Hunter
January 4, 200719 yr Pking in low leveld wild and at mage bank sort of proves that in player vs player the best offence mostly wins
January 4, 200719 yr Author im not sure if dharok could be included in this since whip hits at like what, twice the rate? and with defender in the picture it makes the whip have like highest stats as a 2 hander too sort of. well maybe not exactly highest but it does hit 100 something in the attack stats. but dharok combination might be something to think about considering it gives higher dmg with that special set bonus thing. and thanks for reminding me to put fire cape in the setup
January 4, 200719 yr Pking in low leveld wild and at mage bank sort of proves that in player vs player the best offence mostly wins No, it just shows that the best offence knocks out faster, and leaves less chance for opponent to eat. 99+ all 23rd March 2012 - 2496 total 13th June 2012.9000+ dragon drops! Including draconic visage, d chains, d spears, d2h, d claws, d meds, d legs, d skirts... d bones, d hides :)?I want jagex to put resource dungeons and dungeoneering skill doors to dungeoneering floors so I can dungeon and get dungeoneering xp while I dg so I don't have to dg to get dg exp, but I can dg while I dg :)?
January 4, 200719 yr Pking in low leveld wild and at mage bank sort of proves that in player vs player the best offence mostly wins Errrrrmmm...Not really? I stake in duel arena with Blood/Ice barrage, full mage gear (ahrims mage book fury etc) and I could fairly beat a melee pure ... :P (the best is box staking and they forget to take off mage attacks :mrgreen:)
January 4, 200719 yr Or you could just use Veracs and win in either case 8-) . Retired 2146 overall - 136 combat - 6 skillcapes Plus I think the whole teenage girl thing will end soon (hopefully), because my girlfriend is absolutely in love with him(she is 18), and im beginning to feel threatened by his [Justin Bieber] dashing looks.
January 4, 200719 yr I would say offense. Thanks Jason321 for the sig!^ Proud to have served the Tip.it Crew Drops: 2x D Chain, 1x D Legs, 2x D Left Half, 1x D spear, 2x D med (monsters), 5x D Med (Barrows), 4x D Axe, 2x Zerker, Abyssal whip x1, 7x D BootsBarrows items: 55 (not counting the meds)
January 4, 200719 yr these are almost the same exactly in what they are wearing think of a better comparison to use maybe :ohnoes: 1593th to 99 Farming - July 08.
January 4, 200719 yr with that setup, torags will win it has too much of a defense bonus compared to the rise in attack and strength from rune defender What?
January 4, 200719 yr Best RFD gloves are the Barrow/Dark Gloves. Hmmm... I always thought best offence would be: Dharok Helm Dharok Plate Dharok Legs Dharok Greataxe Fire Cape Fury Amulet Berserker Ring Rune Boots Barrows/Dark Gloves As to who would win? I'd personally say best offence. "A good offence is a good defence.""The best offence is a good defence." Is the correct saying, and that can easily be seen as "Having a good def is the best kind of offence" or "The best offence makes a good def", but either way, verac > dharok. :P I own both, and dharok is better for leveling and verac kills dharoks very quickly. (They hit slow, high numbers while you hit almost twice as fast and constantly hit numbers in the high 20s.) :^_^: I drew that smilie, btw, along with a few more used by this site.Classic bloodveld for lyph3! Although I do like the new ones.Like a ninja, here I was, gone I am now.BUT! I may be back! Add my new account, Dr Bloodveld!
January 4, 200719 yr For the defense, seeing the opponent uses slashattacks(whip) i recommend a warrior ring as it gives extra slashdefence. Berserker gives crushdefence Click here for my guide on how to solo the D Kings
January 5, 200719 yr Do this in a boxing ring so no one loses anything :anxious: This is kind of interesting. I personally think the offense would be better. At least it's better at lower levels :-k
January 5, 200719 yr Pking in low leveld wild and at mage bank sort of proves that in player vs player the best offence mostly wins Range tanks. 40 Def and 70+ Range, They would be tele'ing when I was at half food. Why did I have to lose that password :( Knowledge Talks| | Wisdom Listens~~Heroes Get Remembered, But Legends Never Die~~Xbox Live & Playstation Network Name: Trojann2
January 5, 200719 yr apparently alot of you dont duel :P. go to a duel arena, find a 99 str pure, duel him. (assuming prayer, food, drinks are off) youll win almost every time, even when armor is off. in the wildy people can pot and eat, and pray which (somewhat) makes up for defence. in the duel arena, however, (assuming your fighting with no prayer food or drinks, there is absolutely nothing to make up for defense. id say about 90-95% of pures ive fought at the duel arena were wins. if i lost i fought them again and 99% of the time won the 2nd time around. im putting my money on the defensive guy
January 5, 200719 yr you want a real comparision take a 99 att/str/ 80 def against a 80 att/ 99 str/def. the def will out last every time. i think that high att/def is the way to go. semi-retired as i am the lastest victim of computer crack! AKA... World of Warcraft
January 5, 200719 yr you want a real comparision take a 99 att/str/ 80 def against a 80 att/ 99 str/def. the def will out last every time. i think that high att/def is the way to go. do you mean 99 def/atk and 80 str :?
January 5, 200719 yr what are dark gloves? are they the same as barrow gloves? Dark gloves are the more official name for them. Barrow is what most people call it though, same thing.
January 6, 200719 yr what are dark gloves? are they the same as barrow gloves? yeah, people just call them dark gloves cause they're stupid Click the pic if you wanna see a Ranged Slayer blog.
Create an account or sign in to comment