Wow is overrated, sure the graphics are nice, but the quests suck(and yes, I'vep layed WoW). IMO Guild Wars is awesome. Good story, great graphics, only problem is that Level 20 cap, which will change with Guild Wars 2. Now as for RuneScape being #1? I doubt it, because they are those idiots(flame me, like I care...) that judge a game only on its graphics(which is really stupid, gameplay is a huge factor). And since RuneScape's graphics are pretty bad(but improving!) next to games like WoW, Guild Wars, Silk Road, etc. there's no way Runescape will become #1. Not unless JaGeX goes against their name(Java Game Experts) and starts making RuneScape in say C++ or something... On a second though, Runescape doesn't have the advertising basis that WoW does, either, and that could be a huge factor. Come on JaGeX, advertise on TV! =P~