It's not quite that simple. All the data reveals, when I last looked at it, a MASSIVE reduction in the amount of players online, active accounts, traffic to the site, google hits. It was a lot more serious than just 10K quitters, and those who went to OSRS. Between the bot nuke and the last day that the highscores were P2P exclusive the number of members went from ~575k to ~485k. A 16% drop over 30 months is not really what I would call "massive" considering the trends of the entire MMO market. *I know using 2 data points is VERY bad, but the start and end of P2P only highscores had very similar bot numbers and the time in between had a lot of crazy things happening with bots, trial memberships, and the like.