a new skill, eating :mrgreen:

 

 

 

the same lvls needed and xp as by cooking, that would be really great!

So sharks can be eaten at lvl 80? or whatever lvl they need to be cooked!

 

 

 

That would kill wildy permanent

Is this spam or a joke? If its a joke then its a very stupid one.

i dont hate you

 

 

 

but i hate the idea

 

 

 

so lvl 126 combats that wanna pk can only eat shrimps atm because their 'eating' lvl wouldnt be high enough

 

 

 

it really sounds ridicilous (srry , dunno how to spell), it sounds stupid

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

nota good idea sorry =;

The amount of players would drop to one... you.

 

 

 

:/

Teaching yourself how to eat? :-k

Eating... sounds like a great idea.

 

 

 

At level 60, you can wield a Dragon Spork!

 

 

 

:wall:

The skill could be called Gluttony.

 

 

 

8-)

Oh great, what's next? Stupidity? That means all the smart people will be at level 1 forever and stupid people dominate the highscores.

 

 

 

No. Just no.

Lv 60... Dragon spork lol.

 

Its just not a good idea. The wildy would be killed for good, and the fishing and cooking industries would be nearly killed.

 

No, just no.

 

From a fisherman.

 

(Plus, knowing Jagex, it will be "members only")

Lv 60... Dragon spork lol.

 

Its just not a good idea. The wildy would be killed for good, and the fishing and cooking industries would be nearly killed.

 

No, just no.

 

From a fisherman.

 

(Plus, knowing Jagex, it will be "members only")

 

 

 

no free to play pking. yah dumb idea. :evil: :roll:

Despite the flames you get, I thought about this myself. I say perhaps not make it a skill, but maybe work it into your current hit points. It's strange that someone with 20 hit points can heal full health as people with 99 can only heal 1/5. Additionally, I find it strange that you can eat a whole shark or turtle in one bite without any sort of utensils. It would make much more sense to make you need utensils to eat. This would create a much more complicated food system, with some meant for battle, while others are better for in between training.

 

 

 

Unfortunately, you can't add something like this to a game, you really have to start with it.

Then we add a Walking Skill. And a Talking Skill. A Social Skill. A Seeing Skill. A Hearing Skill (makes the music louder as you level up). A Negotiations Skill. A Karate Skill. A Relaxing Skill. A Meditation Skill. A (gasp!) Killing Skill.

 

 

 

Seriously.

Is this spam or a joke? If its a joke then its a very stupid one.

 

I share your sentiments. This STINKS like SPAM!

Eating... sounds like a great idea.

 

 

 

At level 60, you can wield a Dragon Spork!

 

 

 

:wall:

 

 

 

"you can now wield a Dragon Spork and Dragon Knive" :-k

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:shame: =; :shame:

 

that means a NO

only an american would think eating qualifies as a 'skill'

"This looks tricky to eat"

only an american would think eating qualifies as a 'skill'

 

 

 

I AM AN AMERICAN AND I RESENT THAT REMARK!!! :evil:

 

 

 

 

 

***pummels jjdevine with a rune 2h*** :twisted:

"This looks tricky to eat"

 

 

 

Yeah, it ends up being something like:

 

 

 

"You try to eat a swordfish..."

 

"You end up stabbing yourself through the head..."

 

"Oh Dear! You Are Dead!"

 

 

 

 

 

(Yes, I pulled the idea from another thread to get the point across...)

 

 

 

 

 

This idea earns itself a BIG, FAT ... NO!!!

Lets make it official and call it Mastication. Why not have a skill called Digestion? The more you eat, the better your stomach can handle it, and the more health it heals! If you're not a good enough digester, bad kebabs can slowly kill you. Too much pizza could give you heartburn! Beware the kidney stone!

 

 

 

While we're at it, lets add TV-watching, rolling out of bed, and recovering from a hangover as the next 3 skills.

 

 

 

Totally not being serious.

 

 

 

As a serious response to your (I can only assume) serious suggestion:

 

 

 

RS skills are usually modelled after things in the real world that take skill. Hence, the name skill.

 

 

 

Unless eating is the only and only skill where you progress from drinking breastmilk to eating solids in the first 200 xp, this simply would have nothing to do with reality.

 

 

 

But then again, neither does eating a good lobster help you heal from some guy cutting your arm off. In fact, the only thing food should really do is give you more energy so that you can run further!

We should have a Social Darwinism skill, where you gain levels by questioning the future development of humanity with consideration to people such as the original poster.

We should have a Social Darwinism skill, where you gain levels by questioning the future development of humanity with consideration to people such as the original poster.

 

YES. YES. YES. I SECOND THAT.

only an american would think eating qualifies as a 'skill'

 

 

 

I AM AN AMERICAN AND I RESENT THAT REMARK!!!

 

Me too! Leave it to a non-American to assume that all Americans are clods. We're not all clods; some of us are morons, some are rednecks, some are druggies, some are idiots.

 

You know, just like any well-developed country.

 

 

 

As for the eating skill...why? There's no point to it; it'd be even more useless than Slayer; at least Slayer has some kind of monetary reward. The only reward for Eating would be the ability to benifit from fishing and cooking again.

 

So, no to eating skill.

 

 

 

--Darg--

Is this some kind of joke or r u really serious? :?

Is this some kind of joke or r u really serious? :?

 

 

 

The thread starter was serious, I think. Unluckily for him, he's got serious opposition putting a stop to him.